Schulz's MediaCom VOD Picks
Suscribe to Weekly Updates
* indicates required

View previous campaigns.

Latest Comments

    Get a grip, I bet the other little girl who...
  • ...
    Love the show - Daniel Mansfield
  • On target
    Everyone I have shared your editorial finds it really close...
  • Retired teacher
    Loved reading how such an outstanding citizen was able to...
  • Re: name correction
    Thank you for bringing the error to our attention, Lorianne,...
Prime Suspects: "Villisca: Living with a Mystery," August 10 at the Englert Theatre PDF Print E-mail
Movies - Reviews
Written by Mike Schulz   
Wednesday, 08 August 2007 02:18

Villisca: Living with a MysteryVILLISCA: LIVING WITH A MYSTERY

Just over a year ago, I was sent a DVD screener from area filmmakers Kelly and Tammy Rundle (of the Moline-based Fourth Wall Films) for their feature-length documentary Villisca: Living with a Mystery. I found it to be a beautifully researched and effectively unsettling true-crime thriller, but unfortunately, there never seemed an appropriate time to tell anyone that; since receiving the DVD, the nearest the movie ever came to our area was during a one-night engagement in Cedar Rapids, and so I held off on writing about the film until it made its way closer to the Quad Cities.

On Friday, Villisca will be screened at the Englert Theatre, in conjunction with Landlocked: The Iowa City International Film Festival.

Close enough.

The film's subject matter is touted on the DVD cover as "America's greatest unsolved mystery," which may be a tad hyperbolic, but is no less fascinating for being so: On the morning of June 10, 1912, in the burgeoning burg of Villisca, Iowa, a family of six and two houseguests were found brutally murdered, the apparent victims of both ends of an axe. There were plenty of clues - the murder weapon covered in blood, a skirt draped over a bedroom mirror, a slab of unsliced bacon wrapped in cloth - but they didn't appear to lead anywhere. Or rather, they appeared to lead everywhere; in a matter of weeks, the list of suspects came to include (as the film's theatrical trailer succinctly describes) a state senator, a crazy preacher, a jealous husband, and a tormented drifter.

As the killer was never caught - though a climactic analysis makes a pretty strong case for none of those suspects committing the crime - Villisca is a hypothetical whodunit, and director Kelly Rundle (Tammy serving as co-writer and co-producer) amasses an intimidating amount of found footage and new interviews into a creepy, hypnotic, and thrillingly debatable entertainment.

Yet as its title suggests, Villisca is almost less concerned with the case than the effect it had (and continues to have) on the town's citizenry. The Rundles' chief accomplishment here lies in showing how an atmosphere of mutual mistrust and abject fear turned a once-bustling community - one of the first Iowa townships, we are told, to highly value "music and art and elocution" - into a depressingly insular one, leery of strangers and newly well-armed. On its surface, Villisca: Living with a Mystery is about an octet of killings in a small town. We gradually learn that's only half-true; by the end, this complex and thoroughly impressive work is about the killing of a small town.


Villisca: Living with a Mystery will be screened at the Englert Theatre at 9:30 p.m. on Friday, August 10, and more information on the film is available at (

Comments (1)Add Comment
written by Terre Read, August 14, 2007
My mother lived near Villisca and told me about the axe murder tragedy as I was growing up, so I was anxious to see the movie when it first came out. I finally saw it at a special showing at the Annie Wittenmyer in Davenport, and I know that it showed at Black Hawk College. It was worth the wait! I agree with your review. It is one of the best true-crime documentaries I've ever seen.

Write comment
smaller | bigger