items tagged with Phil Banaszek
Written By: Jeff Ignatius
The July 9 Rock Island Argus/Moline Dispatch article announcing a verdict for Benton Mackenzie on drug charges began like this: “Even as the 12 jurors shuffled into the courtroom to announce their verdict, Benton Mackenzie could already sense his fate. Guilty.”
As storytelling journalism quickly establishing a mood and then getting to the point, it’s pretty good.
Yet with the basic facts of the case never in dispute, the verdict had long been almost a foregone conclusion because of a pre-trial ruling in May – which the Illinois-based newspapers mentioned in trial coverage but didn’t actually cover. Judge Henry Latham ruled that Mackenzie couldn’t claim he grew marijuana out of medical necessity to treat his cancer.
The Quad-City Times, on the other hand, did cover that ruling, and did a decent job explaining the precedent behind it.
But the Benton Mackenzie coverage from both entities, while voluminous, overlooked or ignored frameworks in which daily events could be understood, processed, and put into a more-meaningful context. The story is ultimately not just about one man with terminal cancer facing a criminal trial. Nor does it merely illuminate the general issue of medical marijuana.
Rather, it’s a heart-wrenching, complicated example of something larger: how the justice system deals with an area of rapidly changing law – one that is itself chasing a swift change in public attitudes following decades of calcified prohibition policy.
Read More About The Forest For The Trees: Lessons From Newspaper Coverage Of The Benton Mackenzie Trial And Rock Island County Government...
Written By: Jeff Ignatius
Category: Local News
If a government body wants to spend tens of millions of dollars for a construction project, there are lots of ways to gauge the public temperature.
It’s hard to imagine a more roundabout approach than the one chosen by the Rock Island County Board.
Last week, the board voted to put a referendum on the April 9 ballot, and if your eyes glaze over while reading it, that might be the goal. The measure asks: “Shall the County Board of The County of Rock Island be authorized to expand the purpose of The Rock Island Public Building Commission, Rock Island County, Illinois to include all the powers and authority prescribed by the Public Building Commission Act?”
Of course, most people don’t know what the Rock Island Public Building Commission is, or that it even existed – let alone its current or potentially expanded authority.
And there’s no way to know from the words what the endgame is. There’s no mention of a new or renovated county courthouse or county office building, or of a location, or of a price tag – which could be anywhere from $13 million (the low estimate for a new court facility alone) to $50 million (the high estimate for a new courthouse and county office building in downtown Rock Island).
In short, the referendum appears designed for maximum obfuscation – a seemingly innocuous question about an obscure public body. The move could easily be interpreted as a deceptive attempt to gain public support for something the public otherwise might not support.
Read More About Maximum Obfuscation: Rock Island County Asks Voters For A Blank Check; You’D Never Know It From The Referendum...
There are 2 items tagged with Phil Banaszek. You can view all our tags in the Tag Cloud