The real electoral surprise last week was not in Chicago, where five tired, old incumbent hack aldermen went down to defeat. The big shocker was the Carbondale mayor's race, in which Sheila Simon - the daughter of the late U.S. Senator Paul Simon - was trounced by Republican incumbent Brad Cole.

Simon lost by a dozen percentage points. Back in the multi-candidate February primary, Simon scored well over 50 percent, with Cole finishing in the mid-30s. But Cole staged a remarkable rebound with the help of the Illinois Republican Party and top state legislators.

House Republican Leader Tom Cross had made the race a priority because he was worried that Simon might run for the House if and/or when state Representative Mike Bost (R-Murphysboro) moves to the Senate. The Repubs dumped a ton of money and staff into the race - a move that was almost completely ignored by the local media, which instead concentrated on Simon's high-visibility support from people such as U.S. Senator Dick Durbin and Illinois Attorney General Lisa Madigan.

Cole ran a good, professional race, while Simon's effort was exposed as amateurish and underfunded. Simon's campaign generated support from Democrats from all over Illinois excited about the possibility of watching her move up the ladder. But Cole was endorsed by both the Southern Illinoisan and Southern Illinois University's student paper.

Simon waited way too long to go negative, and when she finally did she muffed the charge. She criticized Cole for some questionable expenses as mayor, but then she was immediately forced to admit that she had approved those same expenses herself as an alderman. Cole was a deputy chief of staff for George Ryan and had even defended Ryan during the campaign on a Chicago radio show, but Simon failed to use that hefty political bomb.

In Chicago, five aldermen - Madeline Haithcock (2nd Ward), Dorothy Tillman (3rd), Shirley Coleman (16th), Michael Chandler (24th), and Ted Matlak (32nd) - all lost their runoff bids.

The biggest surprise may have been Matlak, whose ward was flooded with precinct workers from just about every white political Machine organization in the city. The 32nd has been controlled by the Machine for almost 80 years, going back to former Congressman Dan Rostenkowski's father, but Matlak didn't bother much with constituent services and was no longer a good fit in a ward that had completely gentrified.

Tillman lost by about 8 percentage points, despite being endorsed by just about every black political leader from Chicago, including Barack Obama. Haithcock was trounced by more than 30 points.

Alderman Berny Stone (50th) held on to defeat the hard-charging Naisy Dolar, 53-47. Stone ran a pathetic campaign in February's first round, but he brought in some topnotch people (including former House staffer and statehouse lobbyist Mike Noonan) and strongly defended his record, something he didn't do before the February vote.

The biggest Chicago winner was probably the unions, which backed several victorious candidates by financing their races and providing precinct workers and direct mail. While their candidates won, specific union issues weren't really part of the actual campaigns. So the unions have some new friends, but no clear mandate for passing their agenda.

The biggest loser was the old-time black political machine, which suffered devastating losses with the ouster of Haithcock, Tillman, Chandler, and Coleman, and the loss of Darcel Beavers during the first round of voting back in February.

Barack Obama, who styles himself as the epitome of a young, black "new politics" candidate, did not endorse a single one of the bright, new, independent-minded candidates who will be taking the helm of black wards on the South and West sides. Count him as a big loser.

Mayor Richard M. Daley is also generally counted as a loser, mainly because of Alderman Matlak's defeat. Daley had made that a race a top priority, sending in gobs of troops and money. Daley did balance that loss by helping the broken-down Stone hold onto power for another term. Mostly, though, the mayor, wounded by scandals and several ongoing federal investigations of his administration, had no political coattails. For the first time in his entire career, he may have even been a liability.


Rich Miller also publishes Capitol Fax (a daily political newsletter) and (

Support the River Cities' Reader

Get 12 Reader issues mailed monthly for $48/year.

Old School Subscription for Your Support

Get the printed Reader edition mailed to you (or anyone you want) first-class for 12 months for $48.
$24 goes to postage and handling, $24 goes to keeping the doors open!

Click this link to Old School Subscribe now.

Help Keep the Reader Alive and Free Since '93!


"We're the River Cities' Reader, and we've kept the Quad Cities' only independently owned newspaper alive and free since 1993.

So please help the Reader keep going with your one-time, monthly, or annual support. With your financial support the Reader can continue providing uncensored, non-scripted, and independent journalism alongside the Quad Cities' area's most comprehensive cultural coverage." - Todd McGreevy, Publisher