After months of indecision, former Republican Governor Jim Edgar finally announced Friday that he wouldn't run for Illinois governor. Edgar's months-long decision-making process often strained the patience of many political insiders, but it created an excitement that was too thick to cut with an ax. Edgar's appearance last Monday in Naperville, at which he said almost nothing, burned so white-hot that it sucked almost all of the oxygen out of politics in this state. Nobody on the inside seemed much interested in anything else.

And for good reason. It's not every day that a former governor mulls another bid for his old office. Illinois Republicans, viewed by some as almost dead after the George Ryan, Jack Ryan, Alan Keyes, and party-chairmanship debacles, saw an Edgar candidacy as an almost sure way back into power.

Republican leaders still think that other candidates could win next year, mainly because of Governor Rod Blagojevich's absolutely awful poll numbers and ongoing state and federal investigations into his administration. But Edgar, they believe, would have had long political coattails, which could have done everything from helping them recruit better candidates to allowing them to pick up some Downstate legislative seats to staunching the very scary suburban hemorrhaging at the state and local levels that is sapping their strength year after year.

Democrats, once supremely confident of their future, are freaked out about Governor Rod Blagojevich's disastrous poll numbers. Their paranoia increased as Edgar flirted with running again. They're breathing a little easier now.

So what's next for the Republicans?

Edgar's decision means there are now no easy solutions for the Republicans. While they still have a decent shot at the governor's mansion, they are as disorganized and divided as they've ever been.

What Governor Blagojevich and the Democrats need most is a chance to get people to stop thinking about alleged corruption in the Blagojevich administration and the perception by voters that he isn't up to the job, and get them to start thinking about ideology.

The completely pro-life, anti-illegal-immigrant, anti-teacher-tenure, and God-knows-what-else Jim Oberweis, the dairy magnate who fumbled two previous statewide bids and is running for governor this time around, would allow the Democrats to shore up their depressed and embarrassed base and scare the pants off the moderate independents. Campaigns are like conversations with the electorate. And Oberweis, or another far-right primary winner, would allow the Democrats to change the subject.

Oberweis has consistently polled second behind GOP state Treasurer Judy Baar Topinka, so he hasn't been considered a real threat by many pundits, but that could change.

It had been widely assumed that Edgar would quickly endorse Topinka for governor if he didn't run. Topinka is closest to Edgar on ideology of all the declared candidates and the two have been political allies for years.

But when the time came to make his announcement, Edgar endorsed no one.

It turns out that for the previous week or so, Topinka started having second thoughts about running for governor. The long wait for Edgar to make up his mind gave the treasurer time to reflect on what she really wants to do, and she reportedly began to think that a run for the state's top office might not be for her. In the end, Edgar didn't want to endorse someone who might not be a candidate.

It's possible as I write this that Topinka could help try to recruit someone else into the governor's race, but it will be impossible to find a "white knight" who compares with Edgar. If and, more likely, when that effort fails, then Topinka may end up in the governor's race after all.

Topinka wouldn't be as easy for Blagojevich to demonize as someone like Oberweis. But she has been around a long time, and has her share of baggage. Edgar would have been able to raise much more money than Topinka, and there's a real fear among her close friends that Topinka could be overwhelmed by a massive Blagojevich spending spree next fall?if she wins the primary.

Now that Edgar is out, the other, lesser-known candidates will feel emboldened to attack the frontrunner Topinka. All but one of those opponents?Ron Gidwitz being the exception?are far to Topinka's right. Topinka will have to spend big bucks just to have a shot at facing master fundraiser Rod Blagojevich. Money isn't everything, but it's definitely an important thing. Let the games begin.

Rich Miller also publishes Capitol Fax, a daily political newsletter. He can be reached at (

Support the River Cities' Reader

Get 12 Reader issues mailed monthly for $48/year.

Old School Subscription for Your Support

Get the printed Reader edition mailed to you (or anyone you want) first-class for 12 months for $48.
$24 goes to postage and handling, $24 goes to keeping the doors open!

Click this link to Old School Subscribe now.

Help Keep the Reader Alive and Free Since '93!


"We're the River Cities' Reader, and we've kept the Quad Cities' only independently owned newspaper alive and free since 1993.

So please help the Reader keep going with your one-time, monthly, or annual support. With your financial support the Reader can continue providing uncensored, non-scripted, and independent journalism alongside the Quad Cities' area's most comprehensive cultural coverage." - Todd McGreevy, Publisher