If the Gaming Board members had gone along with the staff's two selections, Des Plaines would have been the hands-down winner. The bidding almost definitely would not have escalated as high as it did during the hotly contested three-way auction that developed between Des Plaines and the heavy hitters behind Waukegan and Rosemont. In other words, if left up to staff, Illinois coffers would have received a lot less money for the license.
Staff then claimed in an almost laughable analysis that gamblers at a Rosemont site would bet significantly less than gamblers at a Des Plaines site, even though the Rosemont boat would attract a million more visitors a year than Des Plaines, and the Rosemont locale is closer to the hotels, the convention centers, O'Hare Airport and the expressway exit. That bizarre assessment is the basis for staff's claim that a Des Plaines site would generate more revenue than the Rosemont site.
Staff also cherry-picked one questionable aspect from the Waukegan proposal and used it to bludgeon Harrah's Waukegan bid. According to staff, Harrah's was planning to focus its advertising too heavily on nearby low-income residents. But most other analysts figured the casino would naturally draw from all over the wealthy northern suburbs, Chicago, and even Wisconsin. And there was little doubt in anyone's mind that, of the three finalists, struggling Waukegan was the most economically deserving.
Staff even ignored Des Plaines' offer to kick back $94 million to its casino suitor, Midwest Gaming, over 10 years. The highly unusual taxpayer subsidy was used by the company to boost its auction bid.
Why the intense staff interest in Des Plaines? The easy answer is the suburb offers almost all of the super-prime location advantages of Rosemont without the mob stuff. However, one of the staff's own analyses, which it has refused to release, claimed that the alleged bad boys in Rosemont would try to make a play to control some of the casino swag next door if Des Plaines got the boat. So even that argument falls flat.
But the staff now has some big-time egg on its collective face. In its zeal to steer the boat to Des Plaines, the staff missed one very important thing: the business presence in Des Plaines of one of the most notoriously mobbed-up public figures in recent Cook County history, Jim Dvorak.
Jim "The Bohemian" Dvorak served seven years in a federal prison for corruption. Dvorak allegedly took massive amounts of payoffs from Ernest "Rocco" Infelise, a notorious crime boss who controlled Cicero with an iron fist. Dvorak was the undersheriff of Cook County and the Cook County Republican party chairperson at the time of his downfall.
Dvorak has recently put together two big hotel projects in Des Plaines, apparently helped by his friendship with the city's economic-development director, William Schneider. Schneider was involved at one point with the negotiations to bring the riverboat to his town.
While he was undersheriff, between 1987 and 1989, Dvorak allegedly collected payments of as much as $10,000 a month from Rocco Infelise to lay off raids on his suburban gambling joints.
Dvorak hired over 300 people at the sheriff's office who weren't qualified for their jobs. He also hired 17 "ghost payrollers" who collected over a half-million dollars in salary between 1987 and 1990. He took bribes of cars and jewelry.
A board spokesperson refused last week to say whether the staff had knowledge of Dvorak's close relationship with Des Plaines' economic-development director. Dvorak's activities in Des Plaines were not a big secret to the locals, so staff should have known what was going on over there. Either way, we're owed an explanation.
Rich Miller also publishes Capitol Fax, a daily political newsletter. He can be reached at (http://www.capitolfax.com).