Even at its best, a government cannot be a substitute for our individual and instinctive familial or tribal loyalties. As individuals, we should not, and perhaps cannot, forego these inherent stable and comforting instincts.

So, at its best, a government is just the structure we consent to impose an order on those instincts. This includes setting boundaries, allocating authority, and reconciling conflicts. The goal is then to secure for the consenting families, tribes, and communities that host them the protections to freely pursue what they they seek to be.

Since America's founding – and, in varying forms, throughout human history – families and societal tribes have cultivated and practiced mutual care habits and standards. Such compacts within nations provide supporting social structures, and a common framework within which such consensual arrangements could operate. While a perfect power balance has rarely been complete or equally successful for everyone, the republic structure guaranteed by the U.S. Constitution has succeeded more deliberately than most.

Today, this balance feels uniquely unsettled.

Solutionless Patterns Abound

The best evidence of this is the nature of protests against the government we have. What we demand, what we ignore, and what we assume government should do or not do are reduced to grievance slogans. We march for women’s rights, for racial justice, against inequality, against “kings.” The causes may differ. The language may differ. But the pattern is familiar. A moral claim is asserted. A demand is implied. But rarely are solutions specified in terms of the structures and actions required to achieve them.

The same pattern holds in response. Counter-protesters are not understood as advancing alternative methods or competing approaches to governance. They are presented – and often present themselves – as morally opposed. One side is just; the other is not. One is defending rights; the other is denying them.

Framed this way, there is nothing substantive to reconcile. There is no need to explore and understand which structures work better, which trade-offs are acceptable, or which authorities should decide. There are only assertions of moral absolutism and correctness.

But governance cannot operate on moral assertion alone. It requires the ordering of competing interests, the acceptance of trade-offs, and the design of systems that can be sustained over time. When disagreement is reduced to right versus wrong, those requirements disappear from the conversation.

In fact, submitting to governance at all requires moral compromise. People with deeply held and often incompatible beliefs must still submit to common rules and accept outcomes in others they would not choose for themselves. A devout Catholic and a committed abortion-rights advocate may live in the same community, governed by the same laws; neither fully satisfied, neither fully in control.

Most of us recognize this tension most starkly when an outcome is not in our favor. Those moments are a test – of our willingness to accept limits, and to live within a system that does not always produce our preferred result.

Participation or Submission?

Increasingly, those outcomes are framed not as the ordinary consequence of shared governance, but as the imposition of one side upon another. Our various tribes are consistently defined as divided, and the aggrieved are encouraged to resist those cast as their opponents. In that framing, not prevailing on a moral issue begins to feel less like participation in governance, and more like submission.

Meanwhile, it is impossible to invoke or compel any government action around one's slogans, without submitting or consenting to said government. That is its whole point of "consent of the governed" memorialized in our Declaration of Independence. If the tribes so to speak were not divided, we would not need a government.

Regressing to Tribal Optimization

Much of my thinking on the intersection of tribal instincts, moral values and governance comes from my working career. Operating a small business presents complex problems. The stakes are real. The environment is not something you control, and the outcomes are rarely ideal. You don’t often have the option of asserting a grievance for someone else to solve. Even obvious legal remedies are fraught with cost and uncertainty. In this setting, your community is your company and your co-workers. You recognize your constraints and work to find the best path through them. In the end, you regress to tribal optimization.

That environment also demands moral sacrifice. Is it morally correct to dismiss an economically challenged single mother for performance lapses driven by conflicting demands? That feels wrong. But is it morally correct to continue paying her from the owner’s pocket when others can do the job more competently for the same wage? That also feels wrong. Which is the least wrong choice – and how do you know? There is no answer that does not require moral compromise.

Choosing Amongst Imperfect Outcomes

Governance structures how we choose among imperfect outcomes. In that setting, the burden of that compromise is shared. Everyone understands the constraints. The consequences are visible. The intent to minimize harm is not abstract. It is personal, and it extends beyond leadership to those affected by or witnessing the outcome.

That proximity matters. It is where tribes outperform governments. Not in avoiding difficult choices, but in how those choices are understood, absorbed, and, where possible, softened for those who bear the cost. Experiences like this are not unusual. Most of us have seen them play out in families, communities, workplaces, or churches. And we can be forgiven for wanting to extend that same sense of compassion and balance beyond those immediate circles to as many people as we can influence.

But that is where the realities of structure, intent, and performance begin to assert themselves. Scale matters. Bigger is often not better. And good intentions alone do not assure good outcomes.

In other words, when we assert ourselves in protest, what questions should be asked alongside, or instead of, the slogan? Such inquiry is not objectionable to the grievances, many of which emerge from the same tribal instincts that we celebrate. They are the questions required to govern it – and to decide who governs at all. We have become more comfortable expressing grievance than accepting the responsibility required to resolve it.

“ICE OUT!”

Question: If federal immigration law is not to be enforced, what replaces it? Who decides who is allowed to come and remain? At what level of government should that authority reside?

“End Inequality!”

Question: End it how – and by taking from whom? And from what level of government should that taking be enforced?

“Defund the Police!”

Question: When enforcement is reduced, who is responsible when order breaks down? Which level of government is accountable for that outcome?

“Climate Justice Now!”

Question: What are you willing to give up? Who else, specifically, is required to give up more? Which level of government has the authority to impose those costs?

“No Kings!”

Question: Which powers should be removed from whom? Should any of those powers be re-assigned? If so, to whom governed by which criteria?

These slogans imply the need for expanding or granting authority to direct undefined outcomes. At the same time, many resist the very structures and authorities that would be required to do so. It is not uncommon to see both impulses expressed together.

The irony is that when such questions remain not just unanswered, but unasked, the protests themselves remain a feckless endpoint.

The grievance assertion without remedy stands in for our federal government's edress of said grievances.

Expression Displaces Execution

In short, expression displaces execution. The appearance of action replaces the work of governing. Without structure, this resembles mob rule. If that is intended, then protest once done has served its purpose.

But if the goal is to consent to different governance, not simply to object to current governance, then critical questions must be answered to define critical next steps.

When these steps are not taken, grievance does not resolve. En masse, in a governed society, grievance must resolve either through change or through acceptance. Otherwise, it accumulates. Grievance that is not resolved does not disappear. It compounds. Issues that remain structurally unaddressed – border security, the cost of healthcare, and others – do not fade with time. They persist, and often intensify.

Over time, that accumulation begins to define the broader political environment. The grievances themselves may differ, but the pattern is consistent: problems are named, responses are demanded, and the structures required to resolve them remain unsettled.

250 Years Later, Do We Have a Common Moral Framework?

That, I think, is where we find ourselves just past America's 250th birthday. Many of today’s grievances point toward deeper questions about the intent and structure of our governance.

Should the relationships between our communities, the states of our federation, and the federal government be reconsidered? And how do we administer justice when we no longer share a common moral framework? Are these not the underlying questions at the root of immigration, abortion, environmental management, as well as many other sources of grievance?

The right to object is not in question. Our oft-maligned founders knew this, as expressed in the United States Declaration of Independence:

“That whenever any Form of Government becomes destructive of these ends, it is the Right of the People to alter or to abolish it, and to institute new Government, laying its foundation on such principles and organizing its powers in such form, as to them shall seem most likely to effect their Safety and Happiness.”

The emphasis is not on objection alone, but also on constructing a newly capable government. That is the harder work. It requires more than grievance. It requires a willingness not only to demand outcomes, but to take responsibility for how such outcomes are realized. It requires agreement, perhaps compromise – however imperfect - on structure, authority, and process. Without that work, such protests either just compound dissatisfaction or dissolve into irrelevance.

Perhaps it is not the place of a retired engineer to make these observations. But these are the kinds of questions that emerge from working within systems where trade-offs cannot be avoided. Having recognized how scale can depersonalize moral choices, and having taken responsibility for uncomfortable compromise myself, I further recognize how destructive accumulated and unresolved grievance can be. Right now, I worry we are approaching a period of division that echoes some of the more unsettled chapters in our history.

And yet, the instincts that give rise to these protests are not misplaced. They are rooted in the same familial and tribal loyalties that shape our sense of justice, obligation, and care for others. Regardless of governance, we will all live there, as will our children, and theirs. And those instincts are not the problem. They are the foundation. The challenge is not to suppress such protests, but to translate them into structural solutions.

Instinctive self-determinant, not group think, driven questions are not only worth asking, they require urgent consideration – perhaps even answers – and more fully than I can provide here. That work belongs first to those elected to legislate; but also to those who study, teach, and hold responsibility within our institutions. Those who, like our Founders, bring some appreciation of philosophy and human behavior, now informed by the benefit of a 250-year experiment. And perhaps, the protesters themselves. It is our U.S. Constitution's Bill of Rights that obligates our consented governance to engage principally grounded and genuine grievances with solutions and not rhetoric.

Joel Lorentzen lives in Rock Island, Illinois, and publishes a column on Substack.com titled “Uncommon Sense.” Find all of his essays at Substack.com/@joelelorentzen.

Support the River Cities' Reader

Get 12 Reader issues mailed monthly for $48/year.

Old School Subscription for Your Support

Get the printed Reader edition mailed to you (or anyone you want) first-class for 12 months for $48.
$24 goes to postage and handling, $24 goes to keeping the doors open!

Click this link to Old School Subscribe now.



Help Keep the Reader Alive and Free Since '93!

 

"We're the River Cities' Reader, and we've kept the Quad Cities' only independently owned newspaper alive and free since 1993.

So please help the Reader keep going with your one-time, monthly, or annual support. With your financial support the Reader can continue providing uncensored, non-scripted, and independent journalism alongside the Quad Cities' area's most comprehensive cultural coverage." - Todd McGreevy, Publisher