WASHINGTON - Sen. Chuck Grassley of Iowa is advising Iowans to call or email his offices for a faster response than via postal mail to Washington during the partial government shutdown.  Senate postal operations are largely closed, so Grassley's office in Washington is not getting postal mail deliveries.

"I want Iowans to know their postal mail isn't being delivered to my Washington office right now," Grassley said.  "The lack of delivery will delay the response they receive.  If they need help with an urgent issue, they should call any of my offices in Iowa or Washington or send a message through grassley.senate.gov."

Grassley's Iowa offices are receiving postal mail during the partial government shutdown, in contrast to the Washington office, though it is not possible for Grassley to respond to Iowans by postal mail during the shutdown.   Staff is answering the phones for all six Iowa offices and the Washington office, with constituent services specialists taking calls from Iowans who need help with a problem involving a federal agency.  Some of Grassley's staff is furloughed on a rotating basis in accordance with legal obligations but enough staff is working to receive comments from Iowans, help constituents, meet with Iowans visiting the nation's capital, and help fulfill Grassley's legislative and oversight duties.

Grassley's office phone numbers are available here.  The contact form on grassley.senate.gov is available here.

-30-
Notice: The opinions posted on this site are slip opinions only. Under the Rules of Appellate Procedure a party has a limited number of days to request a rehearing after the filing of an opinion. Also, all slip opinions are subject to modification or correction by the court. Therefore, opinions on this site are not to be considered the final decisions of the court. The official published opinions of the Iowa Supreme Court are those published in the North Western Reporter published by West Group.

Opinions released before April 2006 and available in the archives are posted in Word format. Opinions released after April 2006 are posted to the website in PDF (Portable Document Format).   Note: To open a PDF you must have the free Acrobat Reader installed. PDF format preserves the original appearance of a document without requiring you to possess the software that created that document. For more information about PDF read: Using the Adobe Reader.

For your convenience, the Judicial Branch offers a free e-mail notification service for Supreme Court opinions, Court of Appeals opinions, press releases and orders. To subscribe, click here.

NOTE: Copies of these opinions may be obtained from the Clerk of the Supreme Court, Judicial Branch Building, 1111 East Court Avenue, Des Moines, IA 50319, for a fee of fifty cents per page.

No. 12-1515

JOSHUA N. THOMAS vs. OFFICERS TIM GAVIN, CHUCK TYGART, JESS BERNHARD, and ADAM OLSON; DEPUTY SHERIFF LUKE HRUBY; RESERVE DEPUTY SHERIFF JOSHUA GERSTEN; the CITY OF NORTH LIBERTY, IOWA; and JOHNSON COUNTY, IOWA

No. 13-0480

IOWA SUPREME COURT ATTORNEY DISCIPLINARY BOARD vs. BRIAN JESSE NELSON

"This...whatever it was...has now been joined by another...whatever-it-is...and they are now proceeding in company. Would you mind coming with me, Piglet, in case they turn out to be Hostile Animals?"  ~ Winnie the Pooh

A few months ago I experienced my first bear jam at Yellowstone National Park. In the midst of an afternoon thunderstorm and raindrops the size of Godzilla's tears, my husband slowed to a rolling stop, inching forward and muttered under his breath: "bear jam". Pardon me, what did you say? A what? Oh. OHHHHHH! Slow down! Slow down!

Having grown up in Southern California, the term bear jam sounds like a lollapalooza of rock musicians staged for a long weekend in bear country USA. Not this time.

As you can imagine, it was VERY difficult to contain my excitement when the cars in front of us finally sped away on our side of Yellowstone highway, apparently done viewing a bear. Wow, a BEAR! I was immediately transported to the place where I understood the profound symbolism of bear and it's meaning to those who have this great beast as a totem. First and foremost, bear is one of the most revered and worshiped animals in ancient times; however, the most interesting aspects of bear are the juxtapositions when observing this magnificent creature in its natural habitat.

On the one hand, we see tranquility, benevolence, nurturing and protection. We all know bear is a consummate mother?one of the most devoted mothers in nature. When all conditions are favorable, we will observe an amicable, relaxed, easy-going creature that seems heartily content to languish in sunny spots where it can stretch and snooze in leisure.

On the other hand, bear is a symbol of power and bravery. The Vikings used bearskins to intimidate their enemies and enhance their ferocity in battle. They invoked bear's warrior spiritand courage during the fightknowing that this powerful energy would support their efforts in standing against adversity and taking action.

In ancient times, bear was the master of its domain and carried the meanings of sovereignty and courage. Woe to those who provoked the wrath of bear by encroaching upon its territory.

So here I was, in very close proximity to this powerful being. Reality show and internet-induced terror of bears washed away instantly at the sight of this mass of wet hair ambling silently along the roadside while grabbing masses of vegetation in his mouth, chomping away, and giving no mind to the mayhem of tourists stopping both directions of traffic.

Despite being only a few feet away, this creature short- circuited my line of terror that starts at the frontal lobe and connects electrically to somewhere near the base of the spine. The only priority was to capture a photo of the first bear I had ever seen outside of a zoo...or a distant memory of Winnie the Pooh. I hurriedly snapped off tens of pictures unable to concentrate on f-stop, apertures or lighting. Fortunately, this bear was a cooperative model that continued to amble on without paying any attention to the fervor churning and multiplying from the epicenter of this bear jam.

Click, click, click...all the while trying to keep the rain out of my passenger-side window and off my camera. My husband finally reminded me that we were on a highway and had to move on to provide opportunity for the myriad of other gawkers. Agreed.

As our car regained speed, I sat silently thumbing through my digital archive of the speedy moment with our bear. I noticed on camera what I had not noticed with my naked eyes in the heat of the moment: our bear was quite scuffed up...scars and fur missing from various places on his face, two tags in his clipped or torn ears, and a wide leather collar with a bent piece of metal where something had apparently been torn free in some imagined hostile confrontation. Thinking back to his walk and demeanor, he just looked sore and detached from his star-struck paparazzi.

As the day progressed, I couldn't help but ponder my bear experience. I thought and thought...and thought some more about our battered bear. Our bear?

It is literally impossible to escape the majesty of Yellowstone. In a single day we experienced a showcase of wildlife: wolves, coyote, a bald eagle, several deer, moose, and herds of bison. What an opportunity. We had been invited into these animals' habitat...almost as one of them, I imagined. I tried to explain this abstract homage to my husband who looked like he was in his own pensive, solitary moment. I asked him what he thought of the strife that seems to be a part of bear's life in this park?in bear's own habitat.

His response will forever be etched in my mind...in my heart: "This park is a wonderful place where we have given sanctuary to these animals to thrive. Unfortunately, we took the land from them in the first place, and tried to give it back. We attempted to impose eminent domain against nature. Now, that bear has to carry tags in his ears, he has to have an undignified collar, and he walks among humans as if just offering a glimpse of his fleeting greatness." He further explained that once you've taken what is rightfully theirs, you can never fully give it back.

I looked out my passenger window and gazed into the screen of pouring rain that seemed to heighten my emotions. Maybe these weren't Godzilla's tears after all; maybe they were bear's...

About Noelle Meade-Izzi

Noelle Meade-Izzi is a published author and as self-proclaimed "Natu-journalist". Her passion in nature and wildlife photography stems from her research and study of the wisdom of the animal world, animal symbolism and animal totems. Her book, The Hummingbird That Answered My Heart's Calling, is a testament to the power of nature and its ability to teach and re-connect humans to their true human nature. You can learn more about Noelle at bee-nevolent.com and connect with her on Facebook and Google+.

Washington, D.C. - Congressman Dave Loebsack delivered stories of Iowans who have been affected by the shutdown directly to President Obama during a meeting at the White House yesterday. More than 1,100 Iowans from the Second District have written or called Loebsack since the shutdown began to express their concern and share their personal stories. Excerpts from some of the letters are below. Included with the letters from Iowans, Loebsack also wrote the President to highlight how the shutdown is having an impact on families in the state. A copy of that letter can be found here.

 

"Many Iowans are needlessly hurting due to the government shutdown. It is at the height of irresponsibility that Iowans are being hurt by reckless Washington dysfunction. All of this could be solved immediately by taking the simple step of passing a clean funding resolution to reopen the government," said Congressman Dave Loebsack.

 

"I just got an e-mail from our Crisis Center co-ordinator, informing all of the hotline volunteers, that this shutdown by the Govt means that services from HHS, specifically SAMSHA, are doubtful. This means that the National Suicide Prevention Hotline business offices are furloughed. How do you think that your colleagues would feel if one of their own were in trouble and tried to call Lifeline and be told that Congress has furloughed workers? 'Try to find another way to find help if you're feeling suicidal?' ... this hotline shutdown is just plain rotten."

-Bobbie, Iowa City

"I am a counselor working ... on a small military base.... I am furloughed, so it's obviously impacting me, but it's also impacting my clients, many of whom are active duty service members who have been deployed.

I feel like we government employees are caught in the middle of this very childish drama - through no fault of our own.

Please do your best to end this - I am fed up!!"

- Pella

"I work with WIC families and learned early Monday that the offices would not be printing WIC vouchers for families as a result of the shutdown. This means that women who come in every three months for vouchers for milk, infant formula, cereal, bread, and fresh produce will not be receiving them.

Many of these women time their shopping trips to coincide with receiving WIC. They will be out of milk and out of formula, and look forward to getting some bananas and apples for their families. This is terrible news for them."

-Gale, Davenport

 

###
Former U.S. Marine Officer Offers Tips for Stepping Up
a Man's Game

What kind of man did you think you would be as a boy? Are you that man, or are you even the guy you'd like to be?

Marshall Chamberlain, a man who has experienced life as a U.S. Marine Corps officer, businessman, husband, father, world traveler, boat dweller, writer and all-around adventurer says it might be time for you to step outside of your comfort zone and become one of the few and proud above-average men.
"It's easy to slip into a lifestyle that you don't want," says Chamberlain, a man who prefers goal-oriented pursuits, such as survival classes and building things, over mundane routine. He's also the author of "The Mountain Place of Knowledge," the first book in the Ancestor Series of adventure-thrillers (www.marshallchamberlain.com).

"Over time, the decisions you make accumulate and lead to a place you may not have expected. In some ways, males in our society have lost the art of being free men, so I want to encourage them to make a conscious decision about who they want to be and rigorously pursue that goal."
Chamberlain outlines the path to being an above-average man.

· Be honest with yourself. There's always room for improvement, whether we're talking about average men or above-average men. It may not be easy, but be honest about your weaknesses - really honest. For example, are you where you want to be in terms of physical fitness? How do you feel when you see yourself in the mirror? Being in shape is its own reward, but it also serves just about every other aspect of an above-average man's life, requiring discipline, determination and good judgment. What's on the outside is a dead giveaway to what's inside. Are you fulfilled in your job? Are your relationships unconditional? Do you really have friends?

· Embrace transformation. The journey to becoming an above-average man will be a rocky road; but it will be well worth it with results you can be proud of. It will require change. We are creatures of habit - but would you rather be like a domesticated house pet with a set feeding schedule or a free man who looks forward to life's challenges and opportunities to grow wise? Challenge yourself and you'll find talents and strength you didn't know you had.

· Measure yourself. You can't know if you're improving unless you establish baselines. Fitness is easily measured; review what you're buying at the grocery store right now, and measure your waistline. How many push-ups or pull-ups can you do now, and how many will you be doing in six months? Measure creative and intellectual pursuits. For example, if you're learning a new language notice the improvement in conversation from week to week. Try reading articles in the new language; if you can't understand them at first, try again a month later. If you want to be a good person, understand and practice the characteristics of impeccability.

· Be hungry for life. It's easy and safe to retreat into things that we already know and do. New ideas and activities challenge your brain and body. Think about the assumptions you have about life, and seek out ideas that contradict them. Deeply consider the merits of both, and think about what makes sense after doing so. Consider getting out of the house for a weekend - that could mean something as extreme as a Stone Age survival course, or something more intermediate, like a camping trip. Maybe it's time to experience a new culture in another country. Life is too fascinating to be lulled into a complacent existence.

About Marshall Chamberlain

Marshall Chamberlain is a man focused on his passions, with no time for pets, lawns, plants, puttering around or companion compromises. He has a Master's Degree in Resource Development from Michigan State University and a graduate degree in International Management from the Thunderbird School near Phoenix, Ariz. He was an officer in the U.S. Marine Corps and spent many years in investment banking, venture capital and even a stint as a professional waiter. He is obsessed with preparedness, survival and independence. This combination of traits and an unconditional openness to life lead him to all manner of adventure. Chamberlain's primary worldview is simple but profound?"I'm in awe of the magnificence of this world."

by U.S. Senator Chuck Grassley

For generations, Iowans have answered the call to feed the world.  That noble vocation continues today as farmers across the state haul in the fall harvest.  Their labor will help curb the pangs of hunger and malnutrition in poverty-stricken communities around the world.

Today's 21st century stewards of the soil - from resource-rich Iowa to resource-poor India - sow the seeds of global food security thanks in part to revolutionary advances in biotechnology pioneered by Iowan's own Dr Norman Borlaug.  The late Dr. Borlaug spent a lifetime toiling in the fields of Mexico and India to unlock high-yield crop varieties by researching plant genetics.  Known as the Father of the Green Revolution, Dr. Borlaug is credited with saving a billion people from starvation.  Blending his Midwestern work ethic with an unyielding humanitarian mission to feed the hungry, Dr. Borlaug spread food security to some of the most impoverished places on Earth by advancing agricultural innovation from field to fork.  His legacy is carried on today through the World Food Prize.

Established in 1986, the World Food Prize is a prestigious international award that recognizes outstanding, measurable achievement by individuals who have improved the quality, quantity and availability of food in the world.

Thanks to the visionary leadership of Dr. Borlaug and philanthropic commitment by the John Ruan family, the World Food Prize since 1990 has been headquartered in Des Moines.  Located in the heart of America's breadbasket, Iowa serves as a global agricultural anchor all along the food chain.  The World Food Prize puts Iowa on the map as a global leader to promote scientific innovation and its application to agriculture.  This annual award helps create awareness, understanding, and appreciation for the safety and sustainability of biotechnology.  It inspires policy leaders and the next generation to join the crusade:  nourish the hungry, replace food scarcity with food security and empower resource-poor farmers with high-yield seeds.  With an eye on wiping famine off the face of the Earth, the World Food Prize serves as a catalyst to promote dialogue and acceptance for sustainable stewardship of biotechnology and natural resources.  From food and agriculture science and technology, to manufacturing, marketing, nutrition, economics, poverty alleviation, political leadership and the social sciences, the World Food Prize focuses all eyes on feeding the hungry.

All eyes will be on Iowa this month during a three-day symposium that coincides with the centennial observance of Dr. Borlaug's birth in 1913.  From Oct. 13-16, more than 1,000 scientists, policy experts, political leaders, humanitarians and business leaders from more than 65 countries will gather in Des Moines to discuss:  The Next Borlaug Century:  Biotechnology, Sustainability and Climate Volatility.

Speakers include Tony Blair, the former Prime Minister of Great Britain and Northern Ireland; Ãƒâ€œlafur Ragnar Grímsson, current President of Iceland; and Cardinal Peter K.A. Turkson, President of the Pontifical Council for Justice and Peace, at the Holy See in the Vatican.

The 2013 World Food Prize Laureate Awards will honor three pioneers of agricultural biotechnology whose research conducted two continents apart has helped advance world food security, especially to those in developing countries.  Their discoveries have enabled farmers to feed more people by growing more crops with improved yields that use less water and bear resistance to disease, insects, heat and drought.

Their work should inspire policy makers in Washington to keep the pressure on the U.S. Trade Representative to give agriculture a proper seat at the negotiating table for world trade agreements, derail non-tariff trade barriers with the World Trade Organization, and expand market access for American farm exports, including GMO grain.  Biotechnology offers hope to farmers who are trying to feed their families and make a living off the land in some of the most impoverished areas on the world.

As Iowa's harvest gets underway, let's all keep our eye on the prize. Reaping the benefits of human nature's capacity to innovate and create can solve the volatile swings of Mother Nature and feed a swelling global population expected to reach 9 billion in 2050.  Let's ask ourselves, if we have solutions to nurture natural resources while harvesting more from the land to feed the hungry and raise standards of living around the world, wouldn't it be morally wrong to turn our backs on science, sustainability and food security?

Iowa will celebrate Dr. Norman E Borlaug World Food Prize Day on Oct. 16.  Next spring, a statue of Dr. Borlaug will join the National Statuary Collection in the U.S. Capitol.
By: Betty Hectman

A lot of people are going to be celebrating I Love Yarn Day on October 11.  According to the Craft Yarn Council there are over 50 million people of all ages who knit, crochet or otherwise work with yarn.  And it's no wonder.  It's not just the destination of getting a scarf or sweater; the journey is full of benefits.  Knitting and crocheting are great anxiety busters, offer something productive to do while waiting and can be a social outlet when done with a group.  Want to Join in?

Getting Started

It's great if you have a friend or family member to teach you, but if not, there are other options.  Check out your local yarn store.  According to Lisa Garcia of the Close Knit Circle yarn shop in Tarzana California, for a nominal fee they will teach someone to knit or crochet.  In addition with a yarn purchase comes the invitation to hang out at the group table in the store and get help on a project.  Some of the craft stores like Michael's or Jo-Ann's offer group lessons.  Try your local community college.  Pierce College in Woodland Hills, California offers yarn craft classes as part of their extension program.

If you're more of a do it yourselfer, it is possible to learn on your own.  There are numerous  books on the market, but Betty Hechtman, author of two yarn related mysteries series  suggests doing what she did and trying a kids' kit.  "I found that the instructions were broken down into easy to follow steps with lots of illustrations. And if the instructions would work for a ten-year-old, I figured they would work for me.  I learned how to crochet granny squares with a kit meant for kids and it changed my life."

First Projects

Don't defeat yourself by choosing something too complicated for a first project.  Also, it is best to stick with easy to work with yarn like basic worsted weight.  A scarf is a great project to start with using either this free knitting pattern or this free crochet pattern. Both use only the most basic techniques.

The Beauty of Handmade

Every knit or crocheted item has its own story.  The experience of picking the yarn, making the project and what was going on in your life are all woven into the stitches.  Remember that what makes handmade items special is they look like real hands made them.  That means there might be a wiggly stitch here and there, but just look at it as part of the tale.

About Betty Hechtman

Betty Hechtman is the author of "Yarn to Go," the first book in the Berkley Prime Crime Yarn Retreat mystery series, as well as the author of the best-selling Berkley Prime Crime Crochet mystery series. The eighth book, "For Better or Worsted," comes out in November.  She has also written newspaper and magazine pieces, short stories and screenplays as well as a children's culinary mystery. She has a bachelor of fine arts degree and has been active in handicrafts since she was a small child. Hechtman divides her time between Los Angeles and Chicago.

Bipartisan Bill Would Ensure All Federal Employees - Including Those At The Rock Island Arsenal & Iowa National Guard - Receive Retroactive Pay For Period of Government Shutdown

Washington, D.C. - Today, a bipartisan bill cosponsored by Congressman Dave Loebsack (IA-02) and Congresswoman Cheri Bustos (IL-17) that would protect local workers' pay jeopardized by the federal government shutdown unanimously passed the U.S. House of Representatives. The Federal Employee Retroactive Pay Fairness Act, would ensure that all federal employees, including those at the Rock Island Arsenal in the Quad Cities region and the Iowa National Guard receive full compensation once the government shutdown has ended. This will not only help to make sure that local workers are able to put food on the table, gas in the car and pay their bills, but it will protect the local economy from a drop-off in consumer spending.

"Once again, the hardworking men and women at the Rock Island Arsenal and the Iowa National Guard are being forced to shoulder the effects of reckless political games. Politicians in Washington just don't get it - manufactured crises have real life impacts on families and our economy. This manufactured crisis must end and Washington must get these hardworking Iowans back on the job. I will continue to reach across the aisle to find a bipartisan way forward, and I continue to stand ready to work with anyone willing to put our economy and middle class families ahead of Washington politics," said Congressman Dave Loebsack.

"Working families and small businesses across our region shouldn't be punished because some in Washington have forced us into a government shutdown," said Congresswoman Cheri Bustos.  "I was proud to help lead this bipartisan effort to secure back pay for the dedicated men and women across our region like those at the Rock Island Arsenal and the Peoria Air National Guard.  Today's bill would ensure that furloughed workers and their families won't suffer at the hands of this reckless and irresponsible shutdown."

Earlier this week, Loebsack called on Secretary of Defense Chuck Hagel to ensure that all members of the National Guard receive pay during the government shutdown.  Loebsack also joined World War II and Korean War veterans participating in a Quad Cities Honor Flight at the World War II Memorial in Washington, DC, which has been largely shuttered but now reopened to veterans during the government shutdown.   In addition, Loebsack has cosponsored legislation to cut Members of Congress' pay for every day that the government is shut down and has asked that his own pay be withheld for every day that the shutdown lasts.

###

McNeil Has Served as Director of Operations for Governor's Office Since 2009; Replaces Outgoing Malcolm Weems

CHICAGO - Governor Pat Quinn today appointed Simone McNeil as the acting director of the Department of Central Management Services (CMS), the state government's human resources, technology, management and procurement agency. McNeil has served as the Governor's Director of Operations since 2009. Today's announcement is part of Governor Quinn's commitment to ensuring an efficient and responsive government for the people of Illinois.

"Simone McNeil is an innovative and capable public servant whose extensive experience will prove invaluable in her new position," Governor Quinn said. "I want to thank outgoing director Malcolm Weems for his dedicated service to the state, and we appreciate all that he has done at CMS."

Weems had served as CMS director since April 2012. He resigned to take a position in the private sector.

Simone McNeil brings a depth of management experience as a human resources professional with extensive work in budget management and staff oversight in state government, healthcare and private sector environments.

McNeil has served as Operations Director for the Office of Governor Pat Quinn since 2009, where she directed operations and managed a comprehensive human resources program. During her tenure as Operations Director, she made it a priority to analyze former human resources procedures in order to streamline processes and bring more efficiencies to the Governor's Office.

Previously, McNeil served as Operations Director under then-Lieutenant Governor Quinn where she maintained operations and human resources for all office employees; prepared the annual budget for submission to the General Assembly and managed and monitored federal and private foundation grants. While in the Office of the Lieutenant Governor, McNeil also served as Ethics Officer for the administration, ensuring the compliance of state laws by all employees.

McNeil served as Human Resources Director for the Office of the State Treasurer where she oversaw the hiring process for all new employees, the administration of benefit plans and programs and participated in the negotiation of labor contracts for the state. In the field of healthcare, McNeil was the Human Resources Director for the Washington and Jane Smith Community where she maintained a human resources program for 350 health care professionals. She was also responsible for developing staff strategies that reduced all-staff turnover by 20 percent.

Having received a bachelor's degree from the University of Illinois, McNeil's history in human resources also includes work at the Illinois Department of Public Aid as a personnel officer, and as a Human Resources Consultant for the Illinois State Chamber of Commerce in Chicago.

The Illinois Department of Central Management Services provides a broad range of programs and services to state agencies and the public. These include human resources and employee benefits, information technology and telecommunications, property and facilities management, procurement and business diversity, vehicle fleet management, and media and marketing.

###
WASHINGTON - Senator Chuck Grassley, Ranking Member of the Senate Judiciary Committee, is pressing Director of National Intelligence James Clapper for further explanation as to why employees who are needed to ensure the national security of the United States were furloughed.

In testimony before the Senate Judiciary Committee earlier this week, Clapper said that the partial shutdown of the federal government will increasingly jeopardize the safety and security of the country.

Grassley said that the law allows flexibility for the intelligence community to "except" employees from furloughs who are needed to ensure national security.

In the letter to Clapper, Grassley wrote, "There appears to be no reason why the fundamental national security of the Nation should be compromised during the partial government shutdown."

Here is a copy of the text of Grassley's letter to Clapper.  A signed copy can be found here.

 

October 4, 2013

Via Electronic Transmission

The Honorable James R. Clapper

Director of National Intelligence

Washington, DC 20511

 

Dear Director Clapper:

I write today to follow up on your recent testimony to the Senate Judiciary Committee concerning the effects of the partial government shutdown on the Intelligence Community ("IC").

During your testimony, you asserted that the legal standard governing whether personnel are engaged in excepted activities under the Antideficiency Act, and therefore may continue to work in the absence of appropriations, is whether their activity is "necessary to protect against imminent threat to life or property."[1] As a result of the furloughs affecting the IC, you stated that you could not guarantee that the Nation remains as safe as it was before the shutdown began.  "As each day goes by," you maintained, "the impact and jeopardy to the safety and security of this country will increase."

Respectfully, for the reasons stated below, your testimony appears to reflect both a misreading of the law and a failure of leadership.

There is longstanding authority for the proposition that the necessary national security functions of the federal government are excepted under the Antideficiency Act as "authorized by law," [2] even if their suspension does not imminently threaten the safety of human life or the protection of property.[3] Indeed, a previous Attorney General concluded that the President has the inherent authority to obligate funds to carry out specific powers granted to him by the Constitution, such as those related to national security, on this basis.[4] As far back as 1981, executive departments and agencies were advised that excepted activities include those that "[p]rovide for the national security."[5] The non-partisan Congressional Research Service has concluded that "[n]ational security-related activities, may, then, be among those for which obligations in advance of appropriations are considered to be 'authorized by law' . . . and are permitted independently of

. . . whether or not they protect [against imminent threats to] life or property."[6]

Guidance documents prepared by the Administration relating to the current shutdown appear to reflect this common sense interpretation of the law.  The furlough notice reportedly received by NSA employees on October 1, 2013 listed as excepted functions "[a]ctivities required for national security," including - but not limited to - those involving "the safety of human life or the protection of property."[7] In addition, the contingency plan guidance issued in September 2013 by the Deputy Secretary of Defense, on which you were copied, lists the following as excepted activities: "[c]ommand, control, communications, computer, intelligence, surveillance, and reconnaissance activities required to support national or military requirements necessary for national security."[8]

In light of the above authority and guidance, there appears to be no reason why the fundamental national security of the Nation should be compromised during the partial government shutdown.[9] In fact, it is your role as Director of National Intelligence to ensure that the work the IC performs that is necessary for the Nation's security continues uninterrupted.  You asserted during your testimony that you were considering recalling certain employees from furlough status.  However, under the law, those IC employees necessary to maintain our national security should never have been furloughed in the first place.

In any event, if for whatever reason you believe that the shutdown is interfering with the necessary national security functions of the IC, it is incumbent upon you, as the leader of the IC, to press the President and Congress to work together to pass emergency legislation to adequately fund the IC during the shutdown without delay.

 

Sincerely,

Charles E. Grassley

Ranking Member

Pages