Grassley Questions Contradicting Testimony by Justice Department

Official in Quid Pro Quo with St. Paul

WASHINGTON - Senator Chuck Grassley, Ranking Member of the Senate Judiciary Committee, is pressing a key player in the quid pro quo deal between the Justice Department and St. Paul, Minn. to explain the contradiction between information given in a formal briefing to Senate Judiciary Committee staff and documents provided to the committee after the briefing.

In a letter sent today, Grassley asked Joyce Branda, the Deputy Assistant Attorney General in the Civil Division's Commercial Litigation Branch, to explain seemingly conflicting information she provided during a briefing to Judiciary Committee staff and emails she sent during the department's handling of the deal.

"Documents clearly show that at the time of the briefing, the department was well aware of the 'exchange' between the Justice Department and the city of St. Paul. It makes me wonder whether Ms. Branda was instructed by higher-ups not to call the deal an 'exchange' when she briefed Judiciary Committee staff," Grassley said.

Grassley has been conducting oversight of an apparent quid pro quo deal between the Justice Department and St. Paul, Minn., which turned a blind eye to potentially recovering hundreds of millions of taxpayer dollars. Specifically, the Justice Department agreed not to intervene in a False Claims Act case in exchange for the city of St. Paul's agreement to withdraw a separate case on housing issues that was supposed to be heard by the Supreme Court. The United States was not a party in the case before the Supreme Court, which makes it highly questionable that the Justice Department would find it appropriate to use that case as part of its deal with the city of St. Paul.  Unlike the False Claims Act cases the United States could have joined, and which could have resulted in a recovery of hundreds of millions of taxpayer dollars, there was no direct interest of the United States in the outcome of the Magner case.  House Judiciary Chairman Bob Goodlatte and House Oversight Chairman Darrell Issa are also investigating the deal.

Here is Grassley's letter. A copy of the signed letter and the attachments can be found here.

 

March 26, 2013

VIA ELECTRONIC TRANSMISSION

Joyce R. Branda
Deputy Assistant Attorney General
Civil Division, Commercial Litigation Branch

U.S. Department of Justice

950 Pennsylvania Avenue, NW

Washington, DC 20530


Dear Deputy Assistant Attorney General Branda:

On February 5, 2013, you appeared before Congressional staff to provide information regarding the Department's involvement in the decision of the City of St. Paul, Minnesota, to withdraw its petition for certiorari in Magner v. Gallagher.[1] The briefing was provided to the Majority and Minority staff of the Senate Committee on the Judiciary.  It is my understanding you provided a similar briefing to staff for the House Committee on the Judiciary and the House Committee on Oversight and Government Reform on December 5, 2012.

In the February 5 briefing, you told Committee staff: "We didn't decline to intervene in exchange" for St. Paul withdrawing Magner.  On multiple occasions in the briefing, you disputed the characterization that it was an exchange.  At the time, the Department was withholding documents about this matter from Congress.

However, documents since produced by the Department show that on March 8, 2012, you received a list of significant cases from Michael Granston, then Deputy Director in the Commercial Litigation Branch's Fraud Section, a direct subordinate to you.[2] Twenty-five minutes later, you forwarded the document to Jonathan Olin in the Civil Division front office, writing: "St. Paul updated and edited for clarity[.]"[3] The portion of the document relating to U.S. v. City of St. Paul read:

Government declined to intervene in Newell, and has agreed to decline to intervene in Ellis, in exchange for defendants withdrawal [sic] of cert. petition in Gallagher case (a civil rights action).[4]

Accordingly, I ask that you explain why your assertions to Congressional staff were directly contrary to the documentary record.

Sincerely,

Charles E. Grassley

Ranking Member

 

cc:        The Honorable Patrick Leahy, Chairman

U.S. Senate, Committee on the Judiciary

 

The Honorable Bob Goodlatte, Chairman

U.S. House of Representatives, Committee on the Judiciary

 

The Honorable John Conyers, Jr., Ranking Member

U.S. House of Representatives, Committee on the Judiciary

 

The Honorable Darrell Issa, Chairman

U.S. House of Representatives, Committee on Oversight and Government Reform

 

The Honorable Elijah E. Cummings, Ranking Member

U.S. House of Representatives, Committee on Oversight and Government Reform


The Honorable Michael E. Horowitz, Inspector General U.S. Department of Justice

 

[1] See Magner v. Gallagher, 132 S. Ct. 1306 (Feb. 14,2012) (dismissing writ of certiorari).

2 E-mail from Michael Granston to Joyce Branda (Mar. 8, 2010, 3:25 PM) [HJC/HOGR STP 001402-001404].

3 E-mail from Joyce Branda to Jonathan F. Olin (Mar. 8, 2010, 3:51 PM) [HJC/HOGR STP 001402-001404].

4 "Significant Affirmative Civil and Criminal Matters," updated Mar. 8, 2012 [HJC/HOGR STP 001404] [emphasis added].




(DES MOINES) - Gov. Branstad today penned a letter and had it delivered to all 50 members of the Iowa Senate, expressing support for his nominees to the Board of Regents.

 

In the letter, the governor notes that Craig Lang "successfully restored critical funding for our Regents system over the last two budget cycles and ended a period of annual reductions in state general fund support for the university system."

 

Further, the governor highlighted that Craig Lang "restored university budgets to a position of predictability and stability such that, for the first time in 30 years, the Regents will likely approve a tuition freeze for the next school year."

 

On Robert Cramer, the governor said, "Over the next 5 years, the Board will be considering $1.35 billion in construction projects. Given this aggressive future construction plan, he is uniquely qualified to serve on the Board of Regents. He has worked in the construction industry his entire career and he brings long-term and real-world construction experience to this position. For over 20 years he has worked to determine whether construction projects are financially viable for the company to participate.  The experience will assist the board in maximizing construction dollars."

 

On Dr. Subhash Sahai, the governor wrote, "In particular, as a practicing physician, Dr. Sahai will bring a much-needed perspective to the Board's oversight role in regards to the University of Iowa Hospitals and Clinics (UIHC)."

 

"These three individuals each have a unique and compelling set of qualities that fully qualify them to serve on the Board of Regents, they have my full and unwavering support, and I respectfully ask you to support each of their confirmations before the Iowa Senate," the governor continued. "If you have any question or concern regarding any of these three nominees, I extend to you an invitation to meet with me and discuss this personally.  I am committed to making the time available to answer your questions and attempt to alleviate any concerns."

 

The full text is below:

 

March 26, 2013

 

The Honorable Senator Michael Gronstal

Iowa Senate

Iowa State Capitol Building

Des Moines, IA 50319

 

Dear Senator Gronstal:

 

As Iowa's Governor I take seriously my role in selecting individuals for service on the numerous boards and commissions that serve the citizens of Iowa.  And as a former legislator and President of the Senate, I have great respect for the General Assembly's oversight role, generally, and the Senate's role, specifically, in the confirmation process.

 

There has been much recent discussion regarding the individuals I put forward to serve on the Board of Regents and I write today to support the confirmations of Craig Lang, Robert Cramer, and Subhash Sahai and to share with you my reasoning for bringing these talented individuals forward.

 

Craig Lang

 

Originally appointed to the Board of Regents by Governor Culver, I have found Craig Lang to be a leader of uncommon character who has been willing to pursue the difficult policy decisions necessary to make our Regents institutions among the best in the nation.

 

Amongst many accomplishments, I point to the following as ample evidence to Craig's commitment to our universities, their faculties, and the students they serve:

 

  • Successfully restored critical funding for our Regents system over the last two budget cycles and ended a period of annual reductions in state general fund support for the university system.
  • Restored university budgets to a position of predictability and stability such that, for the first time in 30 years, the Regents will likely approve a tuition freeze for the next school year.
  • Embarked on an effort to recognize the unique funding challenges faced by the University of Northern Iowa and helped secure additional resources and supported needed structural changes that will significantly improve the long term viability of UNI's financial foundation.
  • Spearheaded a transparency effort and created a transparency taskforce to shed much greater light on the management of our state universities and provide Iowans greater access to those leading our institutions.
  • Successfully led the process through which two new outstanding university presidents were hired with little or no controversy and with an unprecedented level of transparency.
  • Developed a plan to gradually eliminate the controversial tuition set aside practice whereby a portion of Iowa student's tuition payments are being used to fund scholarships for other students.

 

While some former members of the Board of Regents have talked about the need to make many of these changes, it was Craig Lang who has used his position as President of the Board to actually make these things happen.

 

Leaders lead--and Craig Lang is a leader.

 

Unfortunately, leadership also often comes with a price and much of the criticism Craig has faced during his confirmation process is the direct result of his willingness to make tough choices in pursuit of these numerous positive outcomes.

 

I believe Craig Lang has earned another term on the Board of Regents and hope you will judge his confirmation based on the body of outstanding work he has done to improve our regents institutions.

 

Robert Cramer

 

Robert Cramer is well known among his peers as a collaborative problem solver who brings to the Board of Regents much needed skills from his career in the construction industry and his leadership of the highly respected Associated General Contractors of Iowa (AGC Iowa).

 

Here are just a few of the reasons I believe Robert Cramer is the right choice to serve on the Board of Regents at this time:

 

  • Over the next 5 years, the Board will be considering $1.35 billion in construction projects.
  • Given this aggressive future construction plan, he is uniquely qualified to serve on the Board of Regents.

o   Construction company owner:  He has worked in the construction industry his entire career and he brings long-term and real-world construction experience to this position.

o   For over 20 years he has worked to determine whether construction projects are financially viable for the company to participate.  The experience will assist the board in maximizing construction dollars.

o   He is a licensed engineer and a graduate of ISU's Engineering School (Construction Engineering).

  • Robert has a long history of volunteering in the construction industry by mentoring students.

o   He served on the Industry Advisory Council for the Construction Engineering School at ISU.

o   He has been a guest speaker for engineering classes and student organizations.

o   He has served as a guest lecturer at the University of Northern Iowa.  For the past two years, he has talked to students in the construction management program about the process of building bridges in Iowa.

  • He has continued to spend much of his volunteer time assisting AGC Iowa in furthering the goals of that 91 year-old association.  He served on the board of AGC 9 years and the executive committee for five years and as the President in 2010.  He is currently Vice-Chairman of the Business Practices Committee which advises the DOT on practical construction solutions that saves taxpayers money.  He remains today as the liaison from AGC to the DOT for improving worker training and recruiting women and minorities to the industry.

In addition to his experience in business and industry, Robert and his wife also personally practice a generosity towards children that changes lives.  He and Lori have provided a much-needed foster home for 16 children over the last four years (some who have come to them with drug addictions)?providing these children with love, safety, security, and support in a very personal effort to give these children a fighting chance to succeed.

 

When I first interviewed Robert, I was struck by his compassion and competence and quickly concluded he would be an outstanding asset on the Board of Regents.

 

The attacks on Mr. Cramer over the last weeks are an unwelcome effort by some to attach an ideological litmus test to the confirmation process that I find more than troublesome.  Our boards and commissions should be populated by individuals with a diversity of backgrounds and beliefs.  Certain beliefs should in no way disqualify an otherwise highly gifted individual from serving on the Board of Regents simply because those beliefs are not shared by particular Senators.

 

Subhash Sahai

 

Dr. Subhash Sahai is a highly respected physician from Webster City who received his medical education at the University of Iowa and has been in private practice since 1976.  I have personally known Dr. Sahai and his family for many years and am certain he will be a productive member of the Board of Regents.

 

In particular, as a practicing physician, Dr. Sahai will bring a much-needed perspective to the Board's oversight role in regards to the University of Iowa Hospitals and Clinics (UIHC).

 

Here are some of the many qualities Dr. Sahai will bring to the Board of Regents:

  • Subhash Sahai emigrated from India to this country in 1967 and Iowa has been his home for the last 40 years.
  • Dr. Sahai has attended all three of our Regents universities and received degrees from two of them (Masters in Biology from the University of Northern Iowa and M.D. from the University of Iowa).
  • He served 14 years on the Webster City School Board.
  • He also served in the Iowa Air National Guard for 14 years.
  • Dr. Sahai currently serves as a Clinical Assistant Professor, University of Iowa, Family Practice Department and Adjunct Clinical Associate Professor, University of Osteopathic Medicine and Health Sciences.
  • His wife and all three of his children are all physicians.

As you can readily see, Dr. Sahai is an exceptional Iowan who will bring significant assets to the Board of Regents and it is my hope he will receive your enthusiastic support with regards to his upcoming confirmation.

 

These three individuals each have a unique and compelling set of qualities that fully qualify them to serve on the Board of Regents, they have my full and unwavering support, and I respectfully ask you to support each of their confirmations before the Iowa Senate.

 

If you have any question or concern regarding any of these three nominees, I extend to you an invitation to meet with me and discuss this personally.  I am committed to making the time available to answer your questions and attempt to alleviate any concerns.

 

If you desire such a meeting, please contact Adam Gregg from my office to schedule a time.

Craig Lang, Robert Cramer, and Subhash Sahai are highly respected Iowans--each with their own unique connections to our Regents institutions and unique skill sets that will assist in our collective governance of the Regents system?and I ask you to support each in their efforts to be confirmed by the Senate for a term of service on our Board of Regents.

Thank you.

 

Sincerely,

 

 

Terry E. Branstad

Governor of Iowa

 

###

Exploring outer space is no flight of fantasy for the Figure Skating Club of the Quad Cities as it brings "Out of This World" to the ice. The Spring Ice Show, set for Sunday, April 7, 2013 will feature figure skating programs themed around rockets, starships, sci-fi and much more.  Picture stormtroopers on skates or little purple people-eaters gliding on ice.  More than 75 local skaters, ranging from preschoolers to seniors, will showcase their themed artistic programs.  Individual, group and synchronized skating numbers will be performed.  A guest performance by U.S. senior level ice dance team, Kseniya Ponomaryova and Oleg Altukhov, rounds out the show.  The team, hailing from Naperville, Illinois recently competed at the U.S. Figure Skating Championships held in Omaha in January 2013.

This event will be taking place at The River's Edge in Davenport Iowa. It is sponsored in part by the Davenport Parks & Recreation Department and Figure Skating Club of the Quad Cities. Like a walk on the moon, this is an exclusive ONE show ONLY event, on Sunday, April 7th at 2:00 p.m.

Out of This World admission will be taken at the door on show day.  Admission:  Adults $10.00, Students/seniors $5.00 and Preschoolers and younger FREE. Seating is limited and available on first arrival basis.  Jackets are recommended for the coolest seats on this planet.  Doors open at 1:30 p.m. with the show starting at 2:00 p.m.

For more information on "Out of This World", go to http://fscqc.org Figure Skating Club of the Quad Cities website.   Direct Inquiries: Sue Schwaegler, FSCQC Show Director, phone at 309-764-2738 or e-mail at SDSCHWAEG@aol.com.

Event Date:          April 7, 2013 2:00 PM

Location:              The River's Edge, 700 W River Dr

Dear Friends, 

This is a Notice of our Annual Meeting: 
March 28, 5:30 pm, at the GAHC, for museum members only.

The following candidates will be considered for approval to the Board, along with other business of the past year:

New:  Jill Grunwald, Ed Littig, Bobbie Rogalski                        

Returning:  Betty Fogle, Stan Reeg, George Straetker, Cal Werner


Thank you for your support of GAHC through membership! If you would like to contribute to our challenge drive, please call 563-322-8844 today! We have 5 days left to reach $180,000!

 

 

Sincerely,

 

GAHC Staff and Board

(DES MOINES) - Gov. Terry E. Branstad today appointed Henry Latham Seventh Judicial District Judge.

Latham, of Eldridge, earned his law degree from the University of Iowa and is currently working in private practice.

The Seventh Judicial Circuit includes Cedar, Clinton, Jackson, Muscatine and Scott counties.

Lawson fills the vacancy left by Chief Judge Alpers.

###

WASHINGTON, March 26, 2013 - On Thursday, March 28, 2013, Agriculture Secretary Tom Vilsack will visit a Hy-Vee grocery store in Sioux Falls, South Dakota to discuss USDA efforts to promote fruit and vegetable consumption, improve childhood nutrition and prevent obesity to raise a healthier generation of Americans. He will also announce the results of a pilot program aimed at increasing fruit and vegetable consumption in America's poorest schools.

 

Secretary Vilsack will discuss USDA's efforts to focus the national conversation on the importance of childhood nutrition, and the need for bold solutions to promote proper nutrition and increased physical activity for today's youngest children. He will highlight the complexity of the challenge we face today and efforts to ensure the availability, affordability and range of options that will help ensure our children get the right nutrition to grow up healthy and strong.

Davenport, Iowa (March 28, 2013) - PechaKucha Night builds at the Figge Art Museum this Thursday at 6:30 p.m. in the museum lobby.

PechaKucha Nights are informal and fun gatherings where creative people get together and share their ideas, works, thoughts, or hobbies in the PechaKucha 20x20 format. This format allows presenters to show 20 slides for 20 seconds each (six minutes and 40 seconds in total) to keep presentations concise and fast-paced. The images advance automatically and the presenter talks along to the images.

PechaKucha Night this Thursday will feature eight presenters including Vincent Briley, Assistant Dean of Academic Advising & Testing at Eastern Iowa Community Colleges; Tony Singh, Senior Vice President of The Singh Group at Merrill Lynch; Diane Franken, artsBASICS Co-Project Director at Davenport Community Schools; Ann Love, Director of Museum Studies at Western Illinois University-Quad Cities;  local artists Matt Pulford and Jeff Tady; local artist and financial advisor of The Singh Group at Merril Lynch, Thomas Behne; and Bruce Walters, professor of art at Western Illinois University.

Devised by Astrid Klein and Mark Dytham of Klein Dytham architecture, the first PechaKucha Night was held in Tokyo in February 2003 as an event for young designers to meet, network and show their work in public. Now, they are held in over 600 cities around the world by a city organizer. According to Figge Director of Development Raelene Pullen, "Our first night was a great success. We will continue to organize this vent on the last Thursday of each month."

Museum admission is free on Thursday evenings and this event will include free light appetizers beginning at 5:30 p.m. along with a cash bar. Thursday is the first of many PechaKucha Nights the Figge will be hosting. For more information on future dates, visit www.figgeartmuseum.org. If you are interested in becoming a presenter please contact Melissa Hueting at mhueting@figgeartmuseum.org.

 -end-

Moline, Illinois - Local entrepreneur is helping bring awareness and raise funds for The Quad City Honor Flight.

Dr. Rebecca Bravard, owner of Quad City Spine Clinic served in The United States Army for 12 years as a Combat Medic and a Black Hawk Helicopter Crew Chief. She decided in January to do her part for our area Veterans after talking to an Honor Flight Participant. "I met a Korean War Veteran who was chosen to go on an Honor Flight. This usually stoic man teared up instantly as he spoke about the opportunity to see the Korean War Memorial in D.C. I was touched and inspired to become passionately involved to help with this cause."

This fundraising drive is only the beginning for the Quad City Spine Clinic says Dr. Bravard, who has been giving back, since she opened her doors in Moline back in 2008. For a $40 donation to The Quad City Honor Flight, the clinic donates a consultation, medical history, orthopedic and neurological exam, x-rays (if necessary), and report of findings to all new patients. A service valued at well over the donation price. She is taking her promotion to area businesses, farmers markets, health and fitness facilities, community churches, and civic groups, along with many other community events. We are trying to raise $1,000 for the Honor Flight.

It is our goal at Quad City Spine Clinic to give back to this great community because We All Need Each Other. "I have lived all over the world and have fallen in love with the people of the Quad Cities who have welcomed me with open arms since I settled here in 2001", says Dr. Rebecca Bravard.

Quad City Spine Clinic can be found on the web at www.quadcityspine.com. Full details can be found at http://www.honorflightqc.com/

Contact: The Quad City Spine Clinic
Address: 1523 47th Avenue Suite 2 Moline, Illinois 61265
Phone: 309.764.7272
Email: qcscpr@gmail.com
URL:http://
www.Quadcityspine.com
MOLINE, IL -- From 4-6 p.m. Saturday, April 6, Western Illinois University-Quad Cities will present the free, public forum, "A Lincoln Symposium: Scholars from the Land of Lincoln." The event will feature a screening of the film, "Young Lincoln," a 30-minute documentary depicting how the joys and trials of Abraham Lincoln's boyhood years shaped his early political notions and molded his character. 

Three noted experts from Quad Cities' area educational institutions will lead discussions after the documentary screening. They include : Stephen Warren, associate professor of history at Augustana College and a Civil War expert who has been a featured scholar on the PBS series "American Experience"; William Hampes, a Black Hawk College psychology professor, noted for his use of humor during his Lincoln presentations; and Timothy Roberts, associate professor of history at Western, who organized "Abraham Lincoln: The Constitutional and Civil War," a traveling exhibition (made possible by the National Endowment for the Humanities) that appeared at WIU-Macomb in 2010 (see www.wiu.edu/news/newsrelease.php?release_id=8375).

The documentary viewing and discussions are being coordinated with The Lincoln Academy of Illinois, which was established in 1964 to recognize the outstanding contributions made by Illinois Citizens toward the social, cultural and technological progress of mankind.

At 6 p.m. Saturday, April 13, the Lincoln Academy will conduct its 49th annual convocation at Augustana College (Rock Island), and six people with ties to the Quad Cities will receive the Order of Lincoln honor, which is bestowed by the State of Illinois and is the state's highest award.

For more information about the convocation at Augustana College, see www.augustana.edu/x55722.xml, or contact Keri Rursch at (309) 794-7721 or via email at kerirursch@augustana.edu.

To find out more about the WIU-QC Public Forum, contact Tami Seitz at (309) 762-9481 or via email at TS-Seitz@wiu.edu.

March 26, 2013

As part of the temporary exhibition, "The Other Side of the Earth" by Chun Arthur Wang, the Muscatine Art Center is hosting a panel discussion about the relationship between Muscatine and China. Mayor DeWayne Hopkins will serve as moderator for the discussion on Thursday, April 4th from 5:15 to 6:30 p.m. in the Muscatine Art Center's Music Room.

Mayor Hopkins will share photographs from his recent delegation trip to Hebei Province and will lead a session that explores the past, present, and future of building a relationship between Muscatine and China. Several panelists were part of the Mayor's delegation while others are "old friends" who hosted Xi Jinping, now the President of the People's Republic of China.

Panelists include members of the Mayor's Muscatine China Initiatives Committee such Tony Joseph, President of the Initiatives Committee and President of Joseph Industries; Sarah Lande, one of Xi Jinping's Old Friends, former Executive Director of Iowa Sister States and also a member of its first Board of Directors; Albert Liu of Musco Sports Lighting; Deb Hutton, President of Muscatine Sister Cities; and Bob Allbee, President of Muscatine Community College.

The panelists will explore topics related to the establishment of the friendship between Hebei and Iowa in the early 1980s, Sister States/Sister Cities past and present initiatives, the purpose of the Mayor's committee, Muscatine companies with operations in China, the 100,000 Strong Initiative, and other efforts to prepare current community and business leaders as well as future generations for working in China and with Chinese leaders.

In addition to the exhibition of paintings by Chun Arthur Wang, the Art Center has on display several cases of items on loan from Joan Axel, an Old Friend of Xi Jinping, and Mayor Hopkins. Among the items are gifts from Xi Jinping including a China Red tea set and two porcelain Chinese Gift Tea containers. Several photo books, scarves, and scrolls are also on display.

The Muscatine Art Center is located at 1314 Mulberry Avenue in Muscatine, Iowa. Hours are Tuesday through Friday from 10:00 a.m. to 5:00 p.m., Thursday evenings until 7:00 p.m., and Saturday and Sunday from 1:00 to 5:00 p.m. Admission is free. Donations are appreciated.

 

 

 


Pages