Notice: The opinions posted on this site are slip opinions only. Under the Rules of Appellate Procedure a party has a limited number of days to request a rehearing after the filing of an opinion. Also, all slip opinions are subject to modification or correction by the court. Therefore, opinions on this site are not to be considered the final decisions of the court. The official published opinions of the Iowa Supreme Court are those published in the North Western Reporter published by West Group.

Opinions released before April 2006 and available in the archives are posted in Word format. Opinions released after April 2006 are posted to the website in PDF (Portable Document Format).   Note: To open a PDF you must have the free Acrobat Reader installed. PDF format preserves the original appearance of a document without requiring you to possess the software that created that document. For more information about PDF read: Using the Adobe Reader.

For your convenience, the Judicial Branch offers a free e-mail notification service for Supreme Court opinions, Court of Appeals opinions, press releases and orders. To subscribe, click here.

NOTE: Copies of these opinions may be obtained from the Clerk of the Supreme Court, Judicial Branch Building, 1111 East Court Avenue, Des Moines, IA 50319, for a fee of fifty cents per page.

No. 11-0552

KLEVER BELISARIO MIRANDA, NANCY CLOTILDE CAMPOVERDE, and CESAR MIRANDA vs. MICHAEL H. SAID and LAW OFFICE OF MICHAEL H. SAID, P.C.

No. 13-0367

IN THE MATTER OF CLARENCE B. MELDRUM, JR., Judicial Magistrate. On application of the Iowa

CHICAGO - Governor Pat Quinn today took action on the following bills:

Bill No.: HB 1533

An Act Concerning: State Government

Exempts employees of the Illinois Sentencing Policy Advisory Council from provisions of the Personnel Code and expands the eligibility for judges able to be appointed thereto.

Action: Signed

Effective Date: Immediate

Bill No.: HB 2754

An Act Concerning: Transportation

Creates the National Wild Turkey Federation license plate and the Curing Childhood Cancer license plate.

Action: Signed

Effective Date: Jan. 1

Bill No.: HB 2771

An Act Concerning: Children

Exempts private attorney-client communications from the reporting requirements of the Abused and Neglected Child Reporting Act.

Action: Signed

Effective Date: Immediate

Bill No.: HB 3359

An Act Concerning: Regulation

Creates the Precious Metal Purchasers Task Force.

Action: Signed

Effective Date: Immediate

Bill No.: HB 3370

An Act Concerning: Local Government

Expands the categories of expenses for which the Metropolitan Water Reclamation District of Greater Chicago may levy taxes.

Action: Signed

Effective Date: Immediate

Bill No.: SB 30

An Act Concerning: Government

Creates the Thomson United States Penitentiary Cession Act.

Action: Signed

Effective Date: Immediate

Bill No.: SB 32

An Act Concerning: State Government

Eliminates requirement that Department of Human Services create a medical advisory panel.

Action: Signed

Effective Date: Immediate

Bill No.: SB 33

An Act Concerning: Safety

Authorizes electronic reporting of environmental data.

Action: Signed

Effective Date: Immediate

Bill No.: SB 47

An Act Concerning: Public Aid

Allows the Department of Healthcare and Family Services to send notice of service via facsimile or electronic mail.

Action: Signed

Effective Date: Immediate

Bill No.: SB 48

An Act Concerning: Civil Law

Repeals the Unified Child Support Services Act.

Action: Signed

Effective Date: Immediate

Bill No.: SB 62

An Act Concerning: Health

Changes the definition of "Clinical Psychologist".

Action: Signed

Effective Date: Immediate

Bill No.: SB 63

An Act Concerning: State Government

Changes the composition of the State Rehabilitation Council and makes other technical changes.

Action: Signed

Effective Date: Immediate

Bill No.: SB 70

An Act Concerning: Gaming

Exempts licensed video gaming establishments from the location restriction if a school or place of worship moves to or is established within the restricted area after the date on which the licensed video gaming establishment obtained its original liquor license.

Action: Signed

Effective Date: Immediate

Bill No.: SB 72

An Act Concerning: Safety

Makes technical changes to several Acts to address the Environmental Protection Agency's audit findings.

Action: Signed

Effective Date: Immediate

Bill No.: SB 93

An Act Concerning: State Government

Permits the placement of detained sexually violent persons in the Chester Mental Health Center.

Action: Signed

Effective Date: Immediate

Bill No.: SB 922

An Act Concerning: Transportation

Permits tow trucks to use white and/or amber oscillating, rotating, or flashing lights.

Action: Signed

Effective Date: Immediate

Bill No.: SB 1169

An Act Concerning: Civil Law

Permits the Department of Healthcare and Family Services to remove the termination date from the income withholding notice for child support.

Action: Signed

Effective Date: Immediate

Bill No.: SB 1191

An Act Concerning: Civil Law

Eliminates the requirement that the Department of Children and Family Services provide a printed copy of the comprehensive list of the unsafe children's products to certain child care facilities.

Action: Signed

Effective Date: Immediate

Bill No.: SB 1213

An Act Concerning: Juvenile Justice

Provides for the indemnification of individuals or organizations that contract with the Department of Juvenile Justice (DJJ), and cleans up statutory references to reflect DJJ's creation as a separate state agency.

Action: Signed

Effective Date: Immediate

Bill No.: SB 1225

An Act Concerning: Aging

Repeals the Senior Citizens Child Care Support Act.

Action: Signed

Effective Date: Immediate

Bill No.: SB 1292

An Act Concerning: Health Facilities

Increases transparency by requiring the Department of Public Health to issue a report of fines received from nursing homes.

Action: Signed

Effective Date: Immediate

Bill No.: SB 1293

An Act Concerning: Warehouses

Changes the refrigerated warehouse licensing cycle for renewals from calendar year to fiscal year.

Action: Signed

Effective Date: Immediate

Bill No.: SB 1321

An Act Concerning: Public Health

Revises information which must be contained in the Department of Public Health's Annual Report regarding its prostate cancer screening program.

Action: Signed

Effective Date: Jan. 1

Bill No.: SB 1322

An Act Concerning: Criminal Law

Requires that the examination to determine whether a person is sexually dangerous be conducted by two qualified evaluators.

Action: Signed

Effective Date: Immediate

Bill No.: SB 1340

An Act Concerning: Civil Law

Exempts DCFS from payment of guardian ad litem fees in specified instances.

Action: Signed

Effective Date: Immediate

Bill No.: SB 1603

An Act Concerning: Finance

Makes several changes that allow the Illinois Finance Authority to operate more efficiently and finance several new projects.

Action: Signed

Effective Date: Immediate

###

Monday, July 15, 2013
Location: Blue Grass City Hall
1. Discussion with Blue Grass City Council at 7:00 pm

Tuesday, July 16, 2013
Committee of the Whole - 8:00 am
Board Room, 1st Floor, Administrative Center
1. Roll Call: Cusack, Earnhardt, Hancock, Minard, Sunderbruch
Facilities & Economic Development
2. Approval of the purchase of a tandem axle truck.
3. Approval of second of three readings to establish a 25 mph speed limit on 1st Av (Vail St) from the county line to the intersection of F58 (200th St.)
4. Approval of support for the route of the Register's Annual Great Bicycle Ride Across Iowa (RAGBRAI) to travel through Scott County and its communities in 2014.
5. Discussion of the Notice of a Public Hearing for the Zoning Text Amendment for the July 18th Board Meeting.
6. Discussion of joint meeting with Planning and Zoning Commission to review Comp Plan and Economic Development.
Human Resources
7. Discussion of pending litigation pursuant to Iowa Code Section 21.5(1)(c). - CLOSED SESSION
8. Approval of agreement with Holmes Murphy and Associates for Employee Health Benefit Consulting Services.
9. Approval of General Policy 40, Title VI - Non-Discrimination.

10. Approval of personnel actions.  Health & Community Services
11. Approval of FY2014 contractual agreement between the Handicapped Development Center and Scott County.
12. Approval of the purchase of one hundred graves and grave liners from Oakdale Memorial Gardens.
Finance & Intergovernmental
13. Approval of third and final reading to amend Scott County Ordinance Chapter 17 entitled Alarm Systems of the Scott County Code by updating numerous sections.
14. Approval of mobile data computer replacement project.
15. Other items of interest.

Tuesday, July 16, 2013
Tax Deed Auction - 10:30 am
Board Room, 1st Floor, Administrative Center

Wednesday, July 17, 2013
Location: Panorama Park
1. Discussion with Panorama Park City Council at 6:00 pm.

Thursday, July 18, 2013
Public Hearing - 5:00 pm
Board Room, 1st Floor, Administrative Center
Public Hea.ring for the Zoning Text Amendment.
Regular Board Meeting - 5:00 pm
Board Room, 1st Floor, Administrative Center

CHICAGO - Governor Pat Quinn today issued a line-item veto of House Bill 214 to suspend pay for Illinois state legislators. Since taking office, the governor has been pushing for comprehensive pension reform to resolve the state's worst-in-the-nation pension crisis. Today's action follows years of legislative inertia on pension reform, while the state's unfunded pension debt grows by millions of dollars a day.

"In this budget, there should be no paychecks for legislators until they get the job done on pension reform," Governor Quinn said. "Pension reform is the most critical job for all of us in public office. I cannot in good conscience approve legislation that provides paychecks to legislators who are not doing their job for the taxpayers."

In addition, Governor Quinn will not accept his salary until the General Assembly sends him a comprehensive pension reform solution.

Illinois' pension crisis was created over 70 years of fiscal mismanagement by previous governors and legislatures. Since taking office, Governor Quinn has worked to restore fiscal stability to the state, making the full pension payment each year and reducing the state's discretionary spending to historic lows. Governor Quinn's efforts to enact pension reform include :

·      In May 2009, Governor Quinn established the Pension Modernization Task Force, which laid the foundation for pension reform efforts.

·      In 2010, despite intense opposition, he fought for and signed into law sweeping pension reform for new hires that are saving billions of dollars.

·      In January 2012, the governor convened a legislative pension reform working group to develop a solution.

·      Three months later, he proposed a comprehensive pension reform plan that erased the unfunded liability and worked to pass this legislation during the legislative session.

·      To avoid credit downgrades, Governor Quinn set several deadlines over the past two years for legislators to enact pension reform. Each time the deadline was blown, taxpayers were on the hook for millions of more dollars in pension debt and numerous downgrades to the state's credit rating. Recently, Illinois' credit rating was downgraded twice in one week to its lowest point in history, which days ago cost taxpayers an additional $130 million over the life of the bonds, in order to maintain critical infrastructure.

·      The governor has called special sessions to address pension reform.

·      He has released several studies on the dire impact of pension inaction on education, with Illinois currently on track to spend more on pensions than education by 2016.

·      The governor has met at length, numerous times with legislative leaders and lawmakers, and repeatedly asked them to vote for comprehensive pension reform.

·      Governor Quinn launched an online campaign to raise awareness about the pension squeeze and urgent need for action.

·      The governor has rejected piecemeal and insufficient pension bills that did not eliminate the pension debt.

·      During his 2013 State of the State and Budget addresses, the governor again laid out standards for pension reform and throughout the session he pushed for Senate Bill 1, which would have eliminated the unfunded liability.

·      In June 2013, the governor proposed a legislative conference committee as a vehicle to break gridlock between the two chambers. He asked the legislative conference committee to act on a compromise that erases the unfunded liability and provides 100 percent funding for the systems by July 9.

Members of the Illinois General Assembly make $67,836 annually, along with additional stipends for leadership positions, both of which were vetoed out today.

"This is an emergency, the taxpayers of Illinois are waiting and there is no excuse for further legislative delay," Governor Quinn added. "The taxpayers cannot afford an endless cycle of delays, excuses and more delays."

###

CHICAGO - Governor Pat Quinn today took action on the following bills:

Bill No.: HB 2401

An Act Concerning: Criminal Law

Permits subdivisions within Cook County to participate in the Redeploy Illinois program.

Action: Signed

Effective Date: Jan. 1

 

Bill No.: HB 2404

An Act Concerning: Courts

Allows 17 year-olds to be tried in juvenile court for felony offenses.

Action: Signed

Effective Date: Jan. 1

 

Bill No.: HB 3172

An Act Concerning: Courts

Allows judges to vacate a finding of delinquency once the juvenile has completed supervision.

Action: Signed

Effective Date: Jan. 1

 

###

New Laws Will Protect Gang Crime Witnesses and Require School Officials to Report Illegal Gang Activity

CHICAGO - Governor Pat Quinn today signed new laws that will help fight gang crimes and protect those who aid law enforcement in these efforts. Today's actions are part of Governor Quinn's agenda to ensure the safety of all people in every community across Illinois.

"All Illinois residents have the right to be safe in their homes, schools and on our streets," Governor Quinn said. "These new laws give us more tools to fight gang violence, crack down on the criminals and protect those who are doing the right thing for public safety."

House Bill 1139, sponsored by State Rep. Emanuel Chris Welch (D-Westchester) and State Sen. Patricia Van Pelt (D-Chicago), creates the Gang Crime Witness Protection Act. The Illinois Criminal Justice Information Authority will establish a Gang Crime Witness Protection Program to assist those who are actively aiding in the prosecution of gang crimes. The program will reimburse counties for assistance they provide victims and witnesses, including temporary living costs and moving expenses. The new law takes effect immediately.

"We have to show people that the law is stronger than street gangs," Welch said. "These bills will help make our schools safer by allowing for greater communication between our principals and law enforcement, and protect those who have the courage to stand up to gang violence."

"This legislation will empower people who might be afraid to testify against members of organized crime regimes," Van Pelt said. "If witnesses are willing to tell the authorities everything they know about criminal activity, they can help stop the violence that is rampant in our communities."

House Bill 2768, also sponsored by State Rep. Welch along with State Sen. Tom Cullerton (D-Villa Park), requires school principals and assistant principals to report any illegal weapons use or possession, or any illegal gang activity, to the proper law enforcement officials. The bill also requires courts and law enforcement officials to notify principals when one of their students is detained for illegal gang activity. The new law takes effect Jan. 1.

As part of his public safety agenda, last week Governor Quinn issued an amendatory veto of House Bill 183, legislation that would allow and regulate the carrying of concealed handguns in public places. The changes address several serious safety problems with the legislation and will make communities safer across the state.

The governor's changes to House Bill 183 limit concealed carry guns to one per person and one ammunition magazine holding no more than 10 cartridges. The changes would also continue to allow local governments to enact assault weapons bans in their communities; keep guns out of establishments serving alcohol, including most family restaurants; and make the presumption that weapons cannot be carried onto private property or in the workplace unless permission to do so is granted. The Governor's changes establish a better law that puts public safety first. Full details of the governor's amendatory veto as well as how to contact your legislator are available at www.KeepIllinoisSafe.org.

The Illinois General Assembly is scheduled to return to Springfield on July 9 to act on Governor Quinn's amendatory veto. They can vote to accept the veto, which requires a three-fifths majority in both the House of Representatives and the Senate, or they could vote to override the veto, which requires a three-fifths majority in both chambers. If both chambers do nothing, House Bill 183 will not be enacted and Illinois' current concealed carry law will be struck down by the courts.

###

Reminds Wrigleyville Crowd that Weapons and Alcohol Don't Mix

CHICAGO - Governor Pat Quinn today visited the popular area surrounding Chicago's Wrigley Field to discuss the importance of common-sense gun laws in Illinois, especially when it comes to concealed carry. Earlier this week Governor Quinn issued an amendatory veto of House Bill 183, legislation that would allow and regulate the carrying of concealed handguns in public places, to address several serious safety problems. One of the governor's critical changes to ensure public safety is to prohibit concealed weapons from public areas such as taverns and restaurants where alcohol is served.

"Guns and alcohol are a toxic mix," Governor Quinn said. "Public safety should never be negotiated away or compromised, and I will never support a flawed concealed carry bill that puts public safety at risk. The common-sense changes I outlined this week make this a better law and I encourage people to visit KeepIllinoisSafe.org, contact their state legislators and urge them to support these important changes."

On Dec. 11, 2012, the United States Court of Appeals for the Seventh Circuit struck down Illinois' ban on the concealed carry of guns in public, an unprecedented ruling. Illinois then had until a court-established deadline of July 9 to pass concealed carry legislation. Legislators took six of the seven months allotted to pass a flawed bill that, despite the governor's objections, included too many provisions inspired by the National Rifle Association.

The governor's critical changes to House Bill 183 establish a better law that puts public safety first. The changes would keep guns out of establishments serving alcohol, including most family restaurants and other places where large amounts of alcohol are consumed; limit the carrying of concealed guns to one and one ammunition-magazine with no more than 10 bullets; and continue to allow local governments to enact assault weapon bans in their communities in the future.

House Bill 183 strips the authority of home-rule governments to enact future laws on assault weapons to protect their local communities. This NRA-inspired provision is not in the interest of public safety or local communities. In fact, these provisions have nothing to do with the right to carry a concealed gun and have no place in this bill. Local governments should always have the right to strengthen their own ordinances to protect the public safety of their communities.

Full details of the governor's amendatory veto as well as how to contact your legislator are available at www.KeepIllinoisSafe.org.

The Illinois General Assembly is scheduled to return to Springfield on July 9 to act on Governor Quinn's amendatory veto. They can vote to accept the veto, which requires a three-fifths majority in both the House of Representatives and the Senate, or they could vote to override the veto, which requires a three-fifths majority in both chambers. If both chambers do nothing, House Bill 183 will not be enacted and Illinois' current concealed carry law will be struck down by the courts

###

CHICAGO - Governor Pat Quinn today took action on the following bills:

Bill No.: HB 192

An Act Concerning: Education

Allows Lake County Township High School District 113 to issue bonds to become due within 25 years.

Action: Signed

Effective Date: Immediate

 

Bill No.: HB 479

An Act Concerning: Local Government

Allows the Illinois Medical District Commission, rather than the Auditor General, to provide its annual audits to the General Assembly.

Action: Signed

Effective Date: Immediate

 

Bill No.: HB 513

An Act Concerning: Education

Requires Governor's State University to provide the names of individuals enrolled in alternative teaching certification programs and extends the deadline for those individuals to complete the programs.

Action: Signed

Effective Date: Immediate

 

Bill No.: HB 982

An Act Concerning: Insurance

Allows the charging of assets for another business a company conducts if the separate account is subject to guarantees, so long as the contract does not specify that the assets are insulated.

Action: Signed

Effective Date: Immediate

 

Bill No.: HB 3390

An Act Concerning: Civil Law

Implements operational efficiencies and cost-cutting measures for the administration of the Workers' Compensation Commission.

Action: Signed

Effective Date: Immediate

 

Bill No.: SB 626

An Act Concerning: Regulation

Ensures that Early Intervention Services is in compliance with new federal regulation.

Action: Signed

Effective Date: Immediate

 

Bill No.: SB 1366

An Act Concerning: Public Employee Benefits

Extends the Early Retirement Without Discount Option under the Teachers' Retirement System for three years, provided certain conditions are met.

Action: Signed

Effective Date: Immediate

 

Bill No.: SB 1584

An Act Concerning: Public Employee Benefits

Requires the boards of local pension systems within the City of Chicago to continue to subsidize retiree health care costs for the City of Chicago.

Action: Signed

Effective Date: Immediate

 

Bill No.: SB 1621

An Act Concerning: State Government

Repeals or makes permissive several unfunded or unduly burdensome mandates for State agencies.

Action: Signed

Effective Date: Immediate

 

Bill No.: SB 1664

An Act Concerning: Regulation

Makes technical changes to and extends the sunset dates of the Public Utilities Act, Cable and Video Competition Law of 2007, and the Wireless Emergency Telephone System Act.

Action: Signed

Effective Date: Immediate

 

Bill No.: SB 1688

An Act Concerning: Education

Eliminates the community college districts' non-residential gross square footage calculation requirement for grant appropriations.

Action: Signed

Effective Date: Immediate

 

###

DAVENPORT, IA–Waste Commission of Scott County's facilities will be closed on Thursday, July 4, in observance of Independence Day. Normal hours of operation will resume on Friday, July 5. Facilities closed include the following:

  • Scott Area Recycling Center, 5640 Carey Ave., Davenport
  • Household Hazardous Material Facility, 5640 Carey Ave., Davenport
  • Electronic Demanufacturing Facility, 1048 East 59th St., Davenport
  • Scott Area Landfill, County Road Y-48, Buffalo

Waste Commission of Scott County is an inter-governmental agency whose mission is to provide environmentally sound and economically feasible solid waste management for Scott County. For more information about the Commission, please call (563) 381-1300 or visit www.wastecom.com.

# # #
CHICAGO - Governor Pat Quinn today issued the following statement on the U.S. Supreme Court decision that struck down a key portion of the Voting Rights Act of 1965:

"Voting is a fundamental right in our democracy, and the Voting Rights Act has been a critical and effective means to guarantee that right.

"I am disappointed by the Supreme Court decision announced today, which halts nearly 50 years of civil rights progress.

"I join President Obama in urging Congress to pass new legislation that will ensure every American has equal access to the polls. I will contact the members of Illinois' Congressional delegation and urge them to make this a priority."

###

 

Pages