Notice: The opinions posted on this site are slip opinions only. Under the Rules of Appellate Procedure a party has a limited number of days to request a rehearing after the filing of an opinion. Also, all slip opinions are subject to modification or correction by the court. Therefore, opinions on this site are not to be considered the final decisions of the court. The official published opinions of the Iowa Supreme Court are those published in the North Western Reporter published by West Group.

Opinions released before April 2006 and available in the archives are posted in Word format. Opinions released after April 2006 are posted to the website in PDF (Portable Document Format).   Note: To open a PDF you must have the free Acrobat Reader installed. PDF format preserves the original appearance of a document without requiring you to possess the software that created that document. For more information about PDF read: Using the Adobe Reader.

For your convenience, the Judicial Branch offers a free e-mail notification service for Supreme Court opinions, Court of Appeals opinions, press releases and orders. To subscribe, click here.

NOTE: Copies of these opinions may be obtained from the Clerk of the Supreme Court, Judicial Branch Building, 1111 East Court Avenue, Des Moines, IA 50319, for a fee of fifty cents per page.

No. 11-1080

STATE OF IOWA vs. DENEM ANTHONY NULL

No. 11-1214

STATE OF IOWA vs. DESIRAE MONIQUE PEARSON

No. 12-1758

STATE OF IOWA vs. JEFFREY K. RAGLAND
Despite Major Advances, Women's Counselor Says Same-
Gender Infighting among Enduring Problems

It's safe to say that women are on the ascendancy on many accounts:

Throughout the next decade, women will be the beneficiaries of the largest transference of wealth in the history of the United States and control two thirds of consumer wealth in the country.

Women are now the majority of the workforce in the U.S. and fill the majority of managerial positions.

For every two men who earn a college degree, three women will get theirs.

"It's not just college and professional women who are transforming society - and the movement is not simply money-based - because I've witnessed women developing a dramatically new point of view on how we view ourselves," says Xandra "Sunny" Moon, author of "The Power of the Titz...a woman's journey back to her self" (www.sunnymoonspowerworld.com). "I am one of those women."

As a self-described "liberated, 18-wheeler-driving, 40-plus babe," Moon meets a countless number of women who she counsels. Like her, they've suffered physical and emotional abuse as young women. And, like her, after raising a family and enduring a deeply unsatisfying lifestyle, they are climbing out of depression and getting back in touch with the woman they've always wanted to be, she says.

"But, as women, we continue to run into several obstacles; while a woman's role has evolved, much of society has not," Moon says. She lists some of those obstacles:

• Other women: While there certainly is a sisterhood among many women, Moon occasionally runs into some who are fearful, lacking in confidence and, therefore, judgmental. "I've been accused of trying to steal husbands because I embrace and show off positive physical traits such as my large breasts, and I encourage all women to take charge of their beauty," she says. "I can assure you that stealing someone's husband has never been on my to-do list; I'm too happy with my life partner and second husband, Lee Abzu, who coauthored my book."

• Domestic abuse: In the U.S., a woman is beaten every nine seconds; most domestic violence victims are women - 85 percent; it's estimated that 1.3 million women are beaten each year - a number that could be much higher since most abuse is not reported to police. In some cases, emotional abuse can be worse because it works like a "psychic prison," Moon says, keeping women locked in awful relationships year after year.

• Human Trafficking: According to the U.S. Department of State, 80 percent of transnational victims are women and girls, 70 percent of which are supplied to the commercial sex industry. With human trafficking being a $32 billion industry, the problem will be an enduring one into the future, even as women in modernized countries earn key roles in changing the world.

• The other half of the population ... Some intellectuals argue that a modern, post-industrial civilization is simply better suited for women. They argue men tend to be more shiftless, inclined to take risks and, overall, living in a society in which excessive testosterone is a liability. "But it doesn't have to be that way," says Abzu, who adds his outside-the-box relationship with Moon exemplifies an ability to adapt to a changing world. "Women have always been beautiful, which means they've always had power, so it's not a huge leap to think of women as having significant sway in how the world operates." Some say that women have taken a page or two from a male-dominated world in order to get ahead; soon, however, it may be that men are the ones who will need to learn from opposite-gender leaders in society, he says.

About Xandra "Sunny" Moon

Xandra "Sunny" Moon is a survivor who came into her own after age 40. As a younger woman, she endured rape, unlawful imprisonment, mental and emotional abuse, and divorce. She has worked 14 years as a truck driver, during which she has spoken with thousands of women near or at midlife. After raising her four children, she continued her education at Idaho State University and eventually married her second husband and soul mate, Lee Abzu. She now counsels women who are seeking rebirth.

Davenport, Iowa -- On September 5, Iowa State University Extension of Scott County will sponsor the parent support and education program PACT (Parenting All Children Together) for an eight week series. The program is financially supported by Scott County Kids Early Childhood Iowa. The program is designed to educate and offer support to parents and caregivers of children age prenatal through five years old and reside in Scott County.

"Parenting is the most important job we will ever have. It is also the toughest! What we provide our children from birth through age five stays with them for the rest of their life. With this huge responsibility, we need to work together. This series will bring together parents and caregivers who want the very best for the children in their life," said Jennifer Best, Extension Educator and PACT instructor.

The upcoming PACT series is in its fourth year of programing in the Scott County community. "Over the years it has been very rewarding to watch each parent/caregiver open themselves up to the learning process," said Marisa Bloom, Families Program Assistant. "Participants were connected with formal supports offered in our community, and enjoyed forming bonds and creating informal support systems with their peers. PACT is a needed resource for these very reasons."

For participating in the PACT program member will receive a free meal at every session, free child care while adults are learning, a free gift at each session, transportation to get to the sessions if needed, $40 worth of items chosen by the participant if they attend at least 6 of the 8 sessions, fun and friendship with other families, and great information to help parents and caregivers help their children be all they can be.

For more information about PACT or to register, contact Marisa at the Iowa State University Extension office at 563-359-7577 or mbloom@iastate.edu.

 

 

DES MOINES - AFSCME Iowa Council 61 President Danny Homan released the following statement concerning the need for additional staff training at the Iowa Juvenile Home in Toledo and Governor Branstad's comments regarding privatization of the Home:

"Governor Branstad and the Iowa Department of Human Services should immediately accept the offer of free staff training from the National Association of State Mental Health Program Directors. This organization is highly regarded and deals with other similarly-situated public facilities. Accepting their offer of assistance should be a common sense decision for this Administration.

"I want to thank the staff of the Iowa Juvenile Home. They are committed and work very hard to turn around the lives of children who truly need assistance. Much of their hard work may not make it into media reports, but I know that staff truly cares about the home's residents. The frontline staff has no control over management decisions and the amount of training they receive.

"The Governor's interest in privatizing the home is misguided and an attempt to avoid accountability for the failures of the Iowa Juvenile Home management and Department of Human Services leadership. The use of 'isolation rooms' was a decision made by the management of the Iowa Juvenile Home. If Director Palmer was not aware of their use, he should have been.

"Iowans need accountable leadership at the Iowa Juvenile Home and Department of Human Services. Hiring an outside contractor to run the home would diminish public control and oversight.

"The record of privatizing juvenile facilities in this country is a poor one. For-profit facilities put profits ahead of children and even non-profit facilities lack the accountability that comes from being directly overseen by representatives of our elected leaders. Privatized facilities have little incentive to rehabilitate youths: doing so would reduce their revenue.

Some examples of the dangers of privatized facilities include :

  • In Pennsylvania, the developer of a privatized juvenile detention facility bribed two judges to divert children to his facility.
  • One private juvenile detention facility in Mississippi run by GEO Group Inc. was found by US District Court Judge Carlton Reeves to have 'allowed a cesspool of unconstitutional and inhuman acts and conditions to germinate.' Problems at the facility included staff inciting violence between youths, hiring staff with gang affiliations, lack of adequate medical care, and lack of rehabilitation services and educational services provided to youths.

"Furthermore, privately run services are often considered out of sight, out of mind by elected officials, which leads to decreased funding and eventual elimination of services as seen most recently at Abbe Center.

"We call on the Branstad Administration and Department of Human Services leadership to immediately accept the offer of free training by the National Association of State Mental Health Program Directors. Furthermore, they should drop proposals to privatize the home and diminish the Administration's accountability for the manner in which the facility is run."

 

Sources:

CNN Website, 2/24/2009

http://www.cnn.com/2009/CRIME/02/23/pennsylvania.corrupt.judges/

Southern Poverty Law Center Website, 5/3/2012:

http://www.splcenter.org/get-informed/news/splc-investigation-lawsuit-expose-barbaric-conditions-at-for-profit-youth-prison-i

###
Overcoming Parental Challenges; Author, Entertainer &
Former Foster Child Offers Advice

Sesame Street recently addressed a topic that can be hard to talk about, even among adults, and directed it toward children. Alex is the newest character created for the program, introduced in an effort to relate to the 2.7 million children in the United States, younger than age 18, who have a parent in the country's prison system.

"Addressing social issues on a mass scale is always a challenge, and with publicly funded programs being slashed left in right due to the economic downturn, one could be reasonably concerned that underprivileged children are being left behind; fortunately, Alex serves as an example to which young children can relate," says Judy Colella, a musician and author who lived in foster care for part of her childhood. Her young-adult fantasy, "Overcomer - The Journey," is available through her website, www.themacdarachronicles.com.

"Children raised in disadvantaged homes are often shy, intimidated, afraid or angry and don't know how to reach out for help, even if it's just someone to talk to."

For guardians who find themselves in a challenging circumstance while raising a child, Colella offers advice for helping children overcome hardship:

• Heroes don't have to be sexy; they have to be available. You can be your child's hero, and the first step doesn't include a cape, or a multimillion-dollar contract with an NFL team or a starring role alongside Brad Pitt. You simply need to be there with a sympathetic ear. According to the U.S. Census Bureau, 24 million children in America live without their biological father, which often contributes to poverty. But poor families aren't the only ones whose children suffer. Parents with executive, round-the-clock jobs are also often neglecting in their child's emotional support.

• Show children they are not destined to repeat the mistakes of their parent(s). It's a soft bias that often trickles into the minds of disadvantaged kids - that they are doomed to repeat the fate of their parents. This could mean imprisonment, drug addiction or general underachievement. Children are at the mercy of their inexperience, and the idea of an alternative path often isn't driven home to them. Teach your child the enlightenment of measureable results. A sport, a musical instrument or specific attention to school studies is a great way of showing change.

• Understand the power of our social nature. Human beings are hardwired to be social. Children with parents who are not emotionally available can be particularly sensitive to peer pressure and bullying. Be mindful of the influences in your child's life. Positive role models like coaches, teachers and other mentors often prove to be life-changing. If your son or daughter seeks the approval of friends who encourage deviancy and underachievement, it should come as no surprise when they run into trouble.

About Judy Colella

Judy Colella is a musician, singer and author of a young adult fantasy series about a boy from 6th century Ireland who finds himself in an abusive modern-day American foster home. As a child, Cian MacDara must travel across time and continents to fulfill his destiny. Judy, who lived in foster care as a child and was adopted by a loving family, says children and teenagers need to learn the power of the choices they make.

DAVENPORT, IA - On August 13, 2013, James Edward Hall, age 75, of Eldridge, Iowa, was sentenced by United States District Judge John A. Jarvey to 15 years in prison for production of child pornography, announced United States Attorney Nicholas A. Klinefeldt. Judge Jarvey also sentenced Hall to a life term of supervised release.

On November 12, 2012, Hall knowingly induced a minor male to conduct certain acts while Hall recorded the activity. On December 5, 2012, pursuant to a search warrant, a search was conducted at Hall's residence. An onsite preview of Hall's computer was conducted, and the video of the minor was found on the computer. Hall was interviewed and admitted that he had recorded the 15 year old juvenile male in Hall's residence.

This case was investigated by the Scott County Sheriff's Office, and was prosecuted by the United States Attorney's Office for the Southern District of Iowa.

# # #

(RNS) The Evangelical Lutheran Church in America on Wednesday (Aug. 14) elected the Rev. Elizabeth Eaton as the denomination's first female presiding bishop. Eaton received 600 votes against incumbent Presiding Bishop Mark Hanson, who received 287.

Eaton, the current ELCA bishop of the Cleveland-based Northeast Ohio Synod, is married to the Rev. Conrad Selnick, an Episcopal priest. Like Hanson, she is considered a moderate who supported the denomination's decision to allow partnered gay clergy while allowing room for churches to disagree, according to the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette.

A native of Cleveland, she received a master of divinity degree from Harvard Divinity School.

"We are a church that is overwhelmingly European in a culture that is increasingly pluralistic," Eaton told the ELCA Churchwide Assembly in Pittsburgh shortly after the election.

"We need to welcome the gifts of those who come from different places, that is a conversation we need to have as a church."

The ELCA, which has lost members nearly every year since its founding in 1987, experienced a dramatic drop when it lost nearly half a million members in 2010 and 2011.

Hanson is credited with leading the nation's largest Lutheran body ? with more than 4 million members in 9,638 congregations ? with a steady hand during turbulent times as the ELCA wrestled with the gay policy that Hanson favored but was hesitant to push on the larger church.

Even so, under his watch the Chicago-based ELCA saw a small but significant schism as conservatives upset with the decision to allow gay clergy defected to a new rival denomination, the North American Lutheran Church.

The election was a surprise to many, as Hanson was expected to win an unprecedented third term after 12 years in office. Hanson was the third presiding bishop in the denomination's history; three of four finalists for the position were women.

"When I stood before you 12 years ago, I told you this is not an election won, this is a call received. And now this call has been extended to Bishop Eaton," Hanson said at the assembly. "This is a humble and a holy privilege to serve the gospel as the pastor of this whole church."

In June, Lutherans in Los Angeles elected the ELCA's first openly gay bishop, four years after the denomination voted to allow openly gay men and lesbians to serve as clergy.

Eaton joins Episcopal Presiding Bishop Katharine Jefferts Schori, who in 2006 became the first woman to lead a church in the worldwide Anglican Communion. The two churches share a full communion agreement that allows shared clergy and joint ministry.

Eaton will serve a six-year term beginning Nov. 1.

Noting Social Security's importance to millions of Americans including 445,043 Iowans, AARP continues work to protect and strengthen the program.

WASHINGTON, D.C. - On the eve of the 78th anniversary of the creation of Social Security, which provides an average annual retirement benefit of $14,900 to 445,043 older Iowans AARP Executive Vice President Nancy LeaMond issued the following statement:

"In the years since President Franklin D. Roosevelt signed the legislation creating Social Security, it has become the foundation of retirement security in America, lifting tens of millions of seniors, as well as widows, children and people with disabilities, out of poverty. Declining pensions, inadequate savings, shrinking home values, and a difficult job market mean that the promise of Social Security will become increasingly important as today's workers approach retirement.

"Yet, some in Washington want to cut this invaluable program to reduce the deficit. Social Security is a self-financed program, not a piggy bank for deficit reduction. That's why AARP is fighting to stop Congress and the President from cutting Social Security benefits using the 'chained CPI,' a change that would hurt seniors already in retirement as well as veterans, women, children and disabled Americans. Just last week, AARP volunteers delivered to Congress more than 1.5 million signed petitions opposing the chained CPI.

"Social Security is too important to rush changes like the chained CPI, or increasing the eligibility age, into a budget deal. As we look to address Social Security's long-term financial challenges, we must think of the current and future beneficiaries who have earned their benefits and rely on them. Any adjustments to Social Security will affect individuals, families, businesses and our economy as a whole. That's why AARP is calling for a separate debate about responsible solutions that will ensure Social Security's strength for current and future generations.

"For 78 years, Americans have found peace of mind and a measure of financial stability in the modest but critical benefits provided by Social Security. As we reflect on its remarkable success, AARP looks forward to engaging with elected officials, business and non-profit leaders, and the American people in an open, honest conversation about how to strengthen Social Security for the future."

Son of German-Jewish Family Says Understanding is Key

It's easy to understand why the descendant of a 1930s era German-Jewish family would harbor ill feelings toward his family's homeland. However, understanding is precisely why Torkel S Wächter no longer hates the nation that fostered the rise of Adolf Hitler and his Nazi Party.

"My father, Michael, never discussed his upbringing even though he was obsessed with Germany, and I took that as an additional reason to despise the country," says Wächter, who was raised in Sweden. "We were never allowed to talk about it because the pain from the past was still alive in him."

After his father's death, Wächter opened the boxes that had remained sealed all of his life. They were filled with his father's and grandparents' diaries, letters, articles and other documents. From these Wächter wrote "The Investigation," a book that highlights questions about personal responsibility and evil during pre-war Nazi Germany.

In addition, the story of Wächter's family is retold on his website, www.onthisday80yearsago.com, in diary fashion. Posts about both personal and historic events appear on the day they occurred in 1933  -- the 80th anniversary. It's an artistic/literary project called "simulated real time," a way of personalizing for readers events that were inexorably leading to world war eight decades ago.

Wächter says the documents not only revealed meaningful insights to his father's life; they offered a glimpse of a different Germany. It is one he has made his peace with. He explains why:

  • Jews in Germany - the success story: Before the rise of Hitler, Germany had been a unique success story for Jews. From the 1700s to 1933, when there were roughly 522,000 Jews in the country, immigrants were able to flourish there. "It's much more difficult to hate something that you come to understand," Wächter says. "I've realized that my father actually loved the country - he had a great upbringing there. But because of what occurred under Hitler, he felt such betrayal and pain that he could never bring himself to talk about it."

  • Friends of the oppressed: In his book, Wächter describes characters like Nazi and anti-Semite Werner Herbrechtsmeyer and the untrustworthy opportunist Carl Fraude. But also revealed are the close, supportive friends of the Wächter family - Franz Wegener, Hans Heinrich Sierau and Klara Henseler. While there were many desperate and ignorant Germans who happily took to Hitler's philosophy, many forget that German citizens also suffered mightily, both during the ascendancy and decline of Nazism," he says.
  • A rich culture: Finding his father's hidden boxes led Wächter's to an investigation of both his father's past, and the German language and culture. Germany and Austria have produced many giants of western culture, including Goethe, Mozart, Beethoven and many of the most important philosophers, including Leibniz, Kant, Hegel, Schopenhauer, Nietzsche and Wittgenstein, who came from an Austrian-Jewish family.

"I've regained the German citizenship that was taken from my family 20 years before I was born," Wächter says. "I spend much of my time in the Federal Republic of Germany with my family, which includes Gustav Wächter's grandchildren and great-grandchildren."

About Torkel S Wächter

Torkel S Wächter is the son of a German-Jewish family that suffered under the Nazi regime. His book, "The Investigation," outlines the experience as recorded by his paternal grandfather and father. Wächter studied Economic History, Development Theory and languages at the universities of Lund, Melbourne and Barcelona, as well as Jewish Studies at Paideia, The European Institute for Jewish Studies and Architectural Restoration at The Royal University College of Fine Arts in Stockholm. After a stint as a fashion model in Paris and Barcelona, Wächter trained as a diver in the Royal Swedish Navy and then went on to an aviation career. During the 1990s, Wächter served as a First Officer with Scandinavian Airlines and frequently flew into numerous U.S. airports. In 1997, Wächter published his first novel, "Samson", and in 1999 he published the first Swedish e-book. Wächter lives in Stockholm and Barcelona with his architect wife; together they have four children.

Des Moines, August 13, 2013 ? Twenty-two Iowans have applied with the State Judicial Nominating Commission to fill the vacancy on the Iowa Court of Appeals that will occur when Chief Judge Larry J. Eisenhauer retires September 30, 2013.

 

The nominating commission will meet on August 21 and 22, 2013, in the Iowa Supreme Court Courtroom on the fourth floor of the Judicial Branch Building to interview the applicants. The public is invited to observe the interviews in the courtroom. Immediately following the interviews, the commission will begin deliberations to select a slate of three nominees from the group of applicants. Once the commission selects its slate of nominees, the commission will forward those names to the governor. The governor will then have thirty (30) days in which to appoint the new judge.

 

A summary resume, completed questionnaire and writing samples for each candidate will be posted on the Judicial Branch website at:

http://www.iowacourts.gov/State_Judicial_Nominating_Commission/Application_Information/

 

The commission welcomes written comments from the public about the qualifications of any of the applicants. Comments must be submitted to the State Court Administrator, who serves as the commission secretary, by August 20, 2013. Comments may be e-mailed to SupCtNom@iowacourts.gov. Comments may also be mailed to the State Court Administrator, Iowa Judicial Branch Building, 1111 E. Court Ave., Des Moines, Iowa 50319.

 

The 17-member commission is composed of a chair, who is the senior justice of the supreme court other than the chief justice, eight lawyer commissioners elected by lawyers licensed to practice law in Iowa and eight non-lawyer commissioners appointed by the governor and confirmed by the Iowa Senate. With the exception of the commission chair, membership on the commission is limited to one six-year term. Terms are staggered. The Iowa Constitution requires that commission members be chosen without regard to political affiliation.

 

The applicants for the court are:

 

Alan H. Bjork, Johnston, Age 64

Attorney, Bjork McDermott Law

J.D. 1976, Drake University

 

Emily Gould Chafa, Johnston, Age 53

Administrative Law Judge, Dept. of Inspections and Appeals

J.D., 1987, Loyola School of Law

 

Susan Kay Christensen, Harlan, Age 51

District Associate Judge (appointed 2007)?Fourth Judicial District

J.D., 1991, Creighton University

 

Mark Dana Cleve, Davenport, Age 58

District Judge (appointed 1998)?Seventh Judicial District

J.D., 1981, University of Iowa

 

Matt M. Dummermuth, Robins, Age 40

Attorney, Whitaker, Hagenow & Gustoff, LLP

J.D., 1999, Harvard Law School

 

George Scott Eichhorn, Stratford, Age 58

General Counsel, Rueter & Zenor, Co

J.D., 1980, Drake University

 

Sharon Greer, Marshalltown, Age 55

Attorney, Cartwright, Druker & Ryden

J.D., 1982, University of Iowa

 

Peter Christopher Hart, Emmetsburg, Age 60

Assistant County Attorney?Dickinson and Emmet Counties

J.D. 1979, DePaul University

 

Samuel Paul Langholz, Ankeny, Age 33

State Public Defender

J.D., 2008, University of Iowa

 

David Larry Leitner, Johnston, Age 57

Attorney, Leitner Law Office

J.D., 1979, University of Iowa

 

Thomas Arthur Mayes, Des Moines, Age 43

Attorney, Iowa Department of Education

J.D., 1996, University of Iowa

 

Christopher Lee McDonald, Des Moines, Age 38

District Judge (appointed 2012)?Fifth Judicial District

J.D., 2001, University of Iowa

 

Jennifer Lee Miller, Springville, Age 42

Attorney, Wachtel Missry LLP

J.D., 1995, Cornell Law School

 

Douglas Robert Oelschlaeger, Cedar Rapids, Age 56

Attorney, Shuttleworth & Ingersoll

J.D., 1981, University of Iowa

 

Alan Roger Ostergren, Letts, Age 41

County Attorney?Muscatine County

J.D., 1997, Drake University

 

Rebecca Saffin Parrish-Sams, Cumming, Age 42

Attorney?Soldat & Parrish-Sams, PLC

J.D., 1998, University of Iowa

 

Michael Joseph Shubatt, Dubuque, Age 48

District Judge (appointed 2008)?First Judicial District

J.D., 1990, University of Iowa

 

Phillip John Tabor, De Witt, Age 54

District Associate Judge (appointed 2008)?Seventh Judicial District

J.D., 1984, University of Wyoming

 

Frank Cal Tenuta, Sioux City, Age 54

Attorney, Iowa Legal Aid

J.D., 1985, University of Minnesota

 

Jeanie Kunkle Vaudt, West Des Moines, Age 59

Assistant Attorney General

J.D., 1991, Drake University

 

Randy Lee Waagmeester, Rock Rapids, Age 60

Attorney, Waagmeester Law Office

J.D., 1978, Drake University

 

Molly  McConville  Weber, Waukee, Age 39

Law Clerk, U.S. District Court

J.D., 2000, Georgetown University Law Center

 

# # #

Pages