Stacy McKean Herrick, Nathan Johnson, Kady Patterson, Archie Williams, and Jackie Skiles in Funny ValentinesCharacter confusion makes for an enjoyable, lighthearted comedy in Richmond Hill Barn Theatre's current summer offering, Funny Valentines. And though the opening-night performance had a slow and somewhat shaky start in terms of line deliveries, the actors quickly settled into their roles and let their characters' quirks shine through.

D.R. Andersen's script concerns Andy Robbins (Nathan Johnson), a children's book illustrator whose professional successes were the result of his collaborations with his now-ex-wife, Ellen Robbins (Stacy McKean Herrick). When Andy's agent, Howard Williams (Archie Williams), and television program-director, Zan Wilkinson (Kady Patterson), show up with a proposal to create a TV empire centered on "Beanie," the Robbins' popular bear character, Andy has to decide whether to take the money and run or side with his television-despising ex-wife, who's also eight months pregnant with his child. (Phew.) And that's just the groundwork, laid out in the first scene in Andy's New York bachelor apartment, before the really funny stuff happens

Stacy McKean Herrick and Nathan Johnson in Funny ValentinesDirector Jalayne Riewerts did well in utilizing this intimate space and making it feel claustrophobic during the later scenes, when all five characters, including Ellen's mother (Jackie Skiles), are packed onto a futon and a single, swiveling chair, and trying to politely conceal particular secrets from each other. (The scene is made even more hilarious by Zan's ill-timed wardrobe choice.) This was also the scene that best showcased the talents of the actors as a group. The comedic timing was rapid and natural and spot-on here; there were none of the awkward, unbelievable movements and behaviors - a random bout of sneezing to motivate a character toward the bathroom, for example - that punctuated a few of the transitional scenes.

In terms of the individual actors, I thought Johnson was a good fit for his character - a man who's predicted to be "six years old for the rest of [his] life." His facial expressions, particularly the open-mouthed glee he displays when excited, emitted a nice, natural quality of innocence. I didn't care as much for his - or Riewerts' - decision for him to kick his legs in the air like a child having a temper tantrum; the gesture was unnecessary considering Johnson's ability to show his "childish" side in unique, more-organic ways. (A good example of this was his hasty stapling together of his shirt, an act performed because Andy doesn't want to bother with buying new buttons.)

Kady Patterson, Nathan Johnson, and Archie Williams in Funny ValentinesAs the denim-jumper-clad, eight-months-pregnant ex-wife of a man with Peter Pan syndrome, McKean Herrick didn't seem to have as much fun as Patterson did portraying the sensual, lingerie-wearing singleton. (Hey, being eight months pregnant isn't usually much fun in real life, either.) But McKean Herrick did a nice job with her maternal, even-keeled character whose unexpected displays of stubbornness toward her ex-husband were charmingly handled. Patterson, however, was allowed a freer range of physical expression with her role and she used this to her advantage, especially during the scene in which she "overheats" and stands at the front door, desperately fanning her bare legs while the other females are out of the room.

Overall, I found Funny Valentines to be like many other G-rated, middle-caliber comedies in which characters conceal their relationships and intentions from each other and subsequently spend the play's duration figuring these things out. I don't, however, mean to say there's anything wrong with a show feeling familiar or "middle-caliber"; in fact, I think it's sometimes refreshing to be able to sit in an air-conditioned theatre and watch a show that simply strives to amuse and entertain its audience. And Richmond Hill's interpretation of Valentines was lively and fun to watch, a jocular romp with a character trying his best to grow up.


For tickets and information, call (309)944-2244 or visit

Support the River Cities' Reader

Get 12 Reader issues mailed monthly for $48/year.

Old School Subscription for Your Support

Get the printed Reader edition mailed to you (or anyone you want) first-class for 12 months for $48.
$24 goes to postage and handling, $24 goes to keeping the doors open!

Click this link to Old School Subscribe now.

Help Keep the Reader Alive and Free Since '93!


"We're the River Cities' Reader, and we've kept the Quad Cities' only independently owned newspaper alive and free since 1993.

So please help the Reader keep going with your one-time, monthly, or annual support. With your financial support the Reader can continue providing uncensored, non-scripted, and independent journalism alongside the Quad Cities' area's most comprehensive cultural coverage." - Todd McGreevy, Publisher